I'm going to pay a visit to the brew store this weekend - if you were going to buy just 3 or 4 bottles of your favorite brew, what would your choices be?
"favorite" brew?? Is this a trick question? It's like being asked to pick your favorite child. I love them all, but differently. I like too many beers to declare a favorite plus, it really depends on the mood I'm in.
If you're in the mood for something hoppy, but perfectly balanced, you can't go wrong with Victory Hop Devil. Don't let the name put you off, there's definitely hops, but they're offset perfectly, with a good malt backbone.
I know that you stated "bottles", but if you're in the mood for something hoppy, but not balanced, (IMO), snag some Dale's Pale Ale.
If you want something on the dark side, Heavy Seas has a new "English Style" porter, "Deep Six" which is very good. Not sure what they mean by "English Style", (IMO, it has a flavor profile, similar to their Peg Leg Stout.
If you want something on the lighter side, but flavorful, I really, really like the Victory Prima Pils. So much so, that I just tapped a keg of it. For the keg rotation, I set out to find a flavorful, (but lower ABV), beer. My usual rotation is either Heavy Seas Loose Cannon, Victory Hop Devil or DuClaw Hellrazer. They're all good, but the ABV in them is all 6.7% or more. I tried a shit-ton of them, and it came down to Sierra Nevada Nooner and the Prima Pils. Prima Pils won. It fits the bill at 5.3% and delicious.
God help me, I have all of those in my fridge.....