Back to FA itself, I've identified the following positions as positions of need for us as of now for starters:
TE1, WR2, DE2, S, CB2, ILB
I think the good news is that FA will have clear solutions to a number of these roles and I think we can find a starting WR or DE with what will probably be a top 15 pick in this coming draft. My thoughts:
TE1 - There are more names out there but Njoku and Andrews will probably be available, given the presence of Fannin and Likely. Njoku is the better receiver but lacks a bit as a blocker. Andrews is the better all around player but his receiving production has dropped the past few years. Either guy is still an upgrade over Ertz and what we have gotten out of him. Given the presence of Bates and Sinnott, I would go Njoku here
WR2 - As of now, Shaheed, Wan'Dale Robinson, Meyers, Doubs and J. Jennings are some of the guys set to hit free agency. Obviously, some of these guys will be resigned by their teams but some of them such as Jennings will also come available. I am on the boat of letting Deebo go unless he comes back on a reasonable 1 year deal or a cheap multiyear deal but someone will overpay him. I think you have to sign one of the above group. Even if we sign one of these guys, I am also still looking at rd 1 of the draft for another guy to potentially give ourselves a strong trio.
DE2 - I think Armstrong showed this year he is a DE1. He took a big leap up and it is a shame he got hurt because he was heading to the Pro Bowl this year. We could make the big splash and go for Hendrickson and we really should take that risk despite Hendrickson's age to make the DL a real strength next season. However, several other teams will chase him too and odds are someone else will sign him. It is not often an elite player comes available in FA. If we don't sign him, Joey Bosa is balling out in Buffalo and he will get himself a big deal - not sure I want him though given the injury history and what he will command. There is also a nice crop of other promising DEs who will hit FA like Jaelan Phillips, K'Lavon Chiasson, AJ Epenesa, Boye Mafe and Odafe Oweh who will hit FA. If we are looking at this tier and he is available, I really like Boye Mafe. He had a 9 sack 2023 campaign but that fell to 6 last year and he hasn't had any this year despite a decent number of pressures. I'd be open to bringing Wise back as depth and we'll have JJB back. This is also another position I'd take a deep look at in the draft and there will be some good options available to us in rd 1.
S - Savage has played better and better and at least shows coverage ability. I'd bring him back to compete with Quan and Will Harris for a starting spot next year but we absolutely do need another piece. Maybe it's the draft. Maybe it is FA. If we go the FA route, I am sure DQ is taking a close look at Donovan Wilson. I believe we tried to grab him a couple years ago but he went back to the Cowboys. He's had a bad year for the Cowboys so far but he is a playmaker in the box who has had a couple great years with DQ. I think this is a position we have over-optimized for special teams ace types who can't actually play defense at a good level. I think one or two of the Reaves/Owens/Butler combo has to go. Quan and Harris are cut candidates for me in camp next year if we bring in Savage and someone else. As Jay Gruden said, you don't need superstars at safety but you can't have bad safeties starting for you.
CB2 - I hope we move on from Lattimore and move Sainristil outside and evaluate him there. We have seen Sainristil enough at nickel the past year and a half and he is just not good there. We did see a half season of solid play on the outside last year. Yes, he has size deficiencies playing outside but perhaps he is better able to stick with outside receivers in man coverage and isn't going to have to tackle as much. If he can prove he is a solid starter on the outside, then finding a starting nickel corner is way easier. A plus starter like Roger Mcreary is not going to break the bank and is likely looking at a Nate Hobbs type 4 yr/$48M deal. We should also note that the Giants found Dru Phillips in rd 3 last year and the Falcons found Billy Bowman Jr in rd 4 this year and both guys are starting and playing at a high level for their teams. On the other hand, if Sainristil doesn't cut it, I will say that outside CB is really slim pickings and it is possible that Greg Newsome may be the best outside CB who will hit FA. After spending 2 2nds, a 3rd, a 4th and a 6th on CBs the past two drafts, it would be a very tough call to spend the 1st rd pick on yet another one this draft.
ILB - Let's hope Magee sticks and shows he is the green dot guy for next year. I think Luvu would look better next to a faster younger linebacker like Magee. I wouldn't count on them to be starters but let's also hope that Kaho and Medrano continue improving and don't meet the same fate that Hampton met this past training camp. If Magee is looking good, this is another position that I would target to add another athletic young guy in the draft to add to the depth of the room. There are a lot of good young linebackers set to hit FA. I would bet most of them will be resigned but who knows. This is the position to go after for an impact starter if we decide we need one. This group includes Kaden Elliss, Matt Milano, Quincy Williams, Quay Walker, Devin Lloyd, Nate Landman, Jerome Baker and Malcolm Rodriguez.
A bonus one for everyone...
K - We need to add someone to our practice squad and elevate that person later in the year if Gay is not cutting it. I pointed to Lucas Havrisik in another thread who just had a nice run with the Packers while subbing in for McManus. I doubt we bring Gay back next year so why not try to figure out a long term solution now?