It might be. The lesson for me is if a dude doesn't seperate well, as I expressed on ES, that's a big red flag. I saw him as a YAC guy and a good blocker. All of that was correct. But the seperation skills have doomed him IMO.
I loved Laporta before the draft, if I recall he was a year before that, and I recall being blown away by his seperation skills and Sinnott is no Laporta. But it should have been a much bigger point of emphasis from me.
But I am not judging Peters based on what we think here. We are watching these players on youtube clips. they are interviewing the players, watching them in person, interviewing their coaches on and on. They should be able to do better than we do here.