Overall, I'd say Ron was an average to slightly above average coach. I think cancer changed his focus and his passion. When he came back he was not the same guy. He was more checked out and his troops felt it. With the owership change, he figured why even fight and just started going through the motions. I'm not even sure if he realized it.
So by the end, I agree with you, he was a lousy coach, but I think we didn't see him at his best. I don't think he had it in him to give us his best anymore.
I was a Ron defender for a while. But honestly, he just wasn't a very good coach.
There are several things you look for from a head coach:
1. Preparation
2. Staff building
3. Messaging
4. Tone setter
From the start, his teams were ill-prepared, the staff he brought together was one of the worst in the NFL, he was the king of word salad, and with all his talk of building a culture, he never actually did.
On this, I might be the minority, I would value his opinion on football things more than Jay Gruden's, who I see as a complete and total clown nepo-baby. Would he have gotten a HC job if his brother wasn't tight with Bruce? Maybe. But maybe not.
But neither of them were good coach's. Ron was able to ride Cam Newton's success and a pretty stacked team, with an outstanding DC (who's now the HC in Buffalo), to success. When Newton wasn't in God mode and after McDermott left, it was never the same. I get needing a franchise QB, but all the warts which were covered up by Newton were exposed.
Shrug. I think they're both bad. But I respect Ron a little more, maybe solely because he played on the '85 bears.