A few general Quinn/process thoughts:
- I hadn't heard the "too many cooks in the kitchen" thing.
- I think Harris and company ran an ALMOST perfect process. They identified the candidates beforehand, ran them by Peters, and then talked to them as soon as they could, both virtually and in-person. The rules are the rules, and they were as fast as they could be within the rules.
- I wonder why they didn't interview Miami Dolphins OC Frank Smith, because they had time to do so. But he probably wasn't a leading contender due to lack of experience.
- If they wanted to talk to Johnson, Macdonald, Weaver and Glenn, they couldn't do that in person until this Monday. They set up 5 interviews in 3 days and were flying to Detroit to make sure the logistics worked.
- Ben Johnson might/might not have been the favorite going in, but they let it be known through Schefter, Keim and Bram (amongst others) he wasn't the run-away favorite the national media was running with.
- They probably could have hired Quinn or Raheem Morris last week, but then they would have not had the opportunity to talk to "the big 4" who were coaching in the championship games. (Ironically, all lost...)
- They might have wanted Macdonald over Quinn. It's tough to say, and impossible to know. But Seattle had clearly targeted Macdonald, and they hit him with an offer first, and that was that.
- Based on looking back at what Schefter, Keim and Bram have been screaming from the rooftops the last 2 weeks, I wonder if Quinn wasn't the leader in the clubhouse going into this week of interviews anyway, and one of the "big 4" would have had to have knocked their socks off to replace him as the hire.
- It's really unfortunate Johnson pulled out of the interview, because it would have looked "better," at least not like the settled, if they had a chance to interview Johnson and then chose Quinn anyway.
Specific to Quinn, he's a mixed bag. but I think this is interesting: The Falcons fired their GM at the same time they fired Quinn. The last winning season the Falcons have had? 2017, the year they won 10 games under Quinn to get into the playoffs and then won a game.
Since then, they have been:
2018: 7-9
2019: 7-9
2020: 4-12** Quinn went 0-5, then fired. Morris was the interim coach for the remainder of the season
2021: 7-10
2022: 7-10
2023: 7-10
There are a lot of reasons for Quinn's demise in Atlanta, but the 2 notable ones were the defenses were terrible and Matt Ryan got old. And they had to replace Kyle Shanahan, who was one of the best offensive minds in the league. Some of the bad defense can be put on Quinn, but they had a talent problem down there, and still do. To some extent, they had an Atlanta problem more than a Quinn problem. A note on Shanahan leaving though, they did go 10-6 the year after he left, and even in the 7-9 years, the offense wasn't the biggest problem. They were 12th in scoring offense in 2018, and 27th in scoring defense. As they say, "there's your problem right there."
There are things you can't excuse: they SHOULD have won that SB. My goodness. That was a choke job across the board, and Quinn was the head man and has to live with that. There are things he could have probably done better to get more out of the defense, and at the end of the day, you are what your record says you are.
I would have preferred an offensive minded HC, but I'm not as down on this hire as some. I think with any of them, it's "wait and see."
Putting together the staff is going to be the next most important thing to do. Who's running the offense is going to be critically important.