I think my want is simpler.
I want a few dominant players. I don't know that I really care about the position (Fine, I do.) but I want someone who strikes fear in the other side.
Right now, I think we have 2 potentially dominant players. Daniels (when healthy) and Tunsil.
McLaurin is a weapon, but not a dominant one. Even in his very good game against Denver we saw how often he was taken away be their dominant corner. I'd put both Bill and Rodriguez at least a level below that. For the sake of this argument, they are not weapons, but craftsman's tools that when used correctly they can get the job done, but just as a sculptor needs more than a fine chisel, they need the help of other tools to complete the work. Deebo is no longer dominant. Ertz is no longer a weapon. No one on defense is dominant. We have players who can be good. We have players who have the opportunity to step forward into a higher category. Amos and Sainristil seem to fit that in my opinion. I'm less confident about Luvu. Luvu has been a dull blade for much of the year.
Last year, I wanted weapons. I hoped Bill and Lane, speed merchants both, could fill that role and both have flashed. I expect both to get better. In 2026, I hope we find or develop players who can take over a game, someone who can impose their will and make an opposing coordinator fret. I'd love to get one more on offense and at least one on defense and frankly while I would prefer to get a dominant pass rusher to a world class safety, I'm almost convinced that this team needs a world class safety more than a very good pass rusher.
I agree with a lot of this, especially the desire for true “fear factor” players, but I’d frame a few pieces slightly differently.
McLaurin isn’t a high-end separator against man coverage, especially vs longer or more physical CBs. But his contested-catch ability, body control, and downfield tracking still make him a reliable man-beater even when he doesn’t get clean separation. And because he can win vertically or on deep crossers, defenses
still tend to tilt coverage his way. Bill and C-Rod aren’t remotely in his tier, but they’re solid pros—you just don’t build game plans around them in the same way.
Ertz is still a great route runner, but the athletic decline is obvious. He brings almost nothing after the catch now and he’s not stretching anyone vertically. He’s a chain-mover, not a weapon.
Deebo at this stage is more of a quick-game / manufactured-touch guy. As a pure separator he’s limited, and even against zone he’s nowhere close to a WR1—probably not even a true high-end WR2 anymore. Useful player, but not dominant.
On defense, Luvu is an absolute dog, no question about his effort or motor. But even going back to Carolina, he’s always been a mediocre NFL athlete, and when your game is built on effort, instincts, and violence rather than burst or range, you get that up-and-down profile. High floor, low ceiling.
Sainristil is a tough eval because he’s such a high-effort, physical player, but you’re right about the limitations. He’ll tackle, he’ll fill the alley, he’ll compete like crazy, but as a man-coverage corner, I doubt he ever becomes more than a serviceable starter. In a heavy-zone system he can play inside or outside, and his run support probably nudges him toward the slot—but in a man-heavy system, where inside defenders get put in conflict more often and run fits are slower, he’s probably better on the perimeter.
Amos was solid for a rookie. Looks like a guy who can be a steady 7–8 year starter, but I don’t see star traits yet.
And honestly, the last two games say a lot about Quinn—ton of zone variety, constant pre-snap disguise, muddying reads for the QB. But the fact remains: in a zone-heavy defense, a consistent four-man pass rush matters more than a top-end safety. Zones inherently have windows; if you can’t squeeze them with pressure, you become a “bend but don’t break” unit, and eventually someone breaks you.
So yeah—I’m with you on needing true dominators. One more on offense, and at least one on defense, ideally a real difference-maker up front. A star safety helps, but without a legit rush, the ceiling of the defense stays capped.
 }})
