Commanders 2025 Picks

burgold

The Owner's Favorite
Staff member
Joe Gibbs Club Member
Joined
Jul 16, 2011
Messages
6,001
Reaction score
3,963
Points
343
First Round: Josh Conerly


Overview​

Two-year starter whose in-season improvement and performance against Penn State’s Abdul Carter make it easier to project his future. Conerly is proportionally built but lacks ideal play strength. He strains at the point of attack but needs to get his hips and hands synced to improve as a finisher. He moves easily in space and gets to his angles to help spring the run. Conerly sets with smooth slides and ready hands but gets caught over-setting. He has anchor troubles against power that might be challenging to correct. He sees twists and blitzes developing and recovers with athleticism when beaten. Conerly is young and needs more development, but he should become a good starter at tackle or guard.

Strengths​

  • Showed vast improvement as the season progressed.
  • Movements are composed and relatively athletic.
  • Accelerates hard into down blocks.
  • Works with strain at the point of attack and is rarely on the ground.
  • Consistent, well-balanced slides both diagonally and back inside.
  • Throws a sudden punch with good pop.
  • Squeezes B-gap and scans for incoming when rusher voids.

Weaknesses​

  • Lacks pace to collect linebacker on work-up blocks.
  • Needs to improve his play strength and play bigger.
  • Oversets open up the inside door in pass protection.
  • Average bender who relies on forward lean to brace up.
  • Has trouble anchoring against speed-to-power rushers.

Second Round
CB Trey Amos

Overview​

Long press cornerback who proved he could make the jump from the Sun Belt to the SEC without a hitch. Amos can disrupt the release and plays with good short-area movement in man coverage. He can get a little lost at the top of the route and needs occasional safety nets over the top. He has twitchy feet to close and sees the action clearly from zone but can be hampered by indecisiveness, despite favorable instincts. Amos uses physicality and length to shrink the 50/50 odds in his favor. He can play in multiple coverage but is most consistent in zone. Amos needs to ramp up his run support and trust his eyes in space, but he has the goods to become a solid starting outside corner.

Strengths​

  • Possesses foot quickness and size to be a problem in press.
  • Plays with pro coverage agility and transition quickness.
  • Has body control and footwork needed to stay in phase versus NFL routes.
  • Twitchy burst and long arms help with catch disruption.
  • Plant-and-drive is sudden and without stall at the top.
  • Desired pacing, positioning and vision in Cover 3 looks.
  • Allowed sub-19 percent completion rate on throws of 20-plus air yards for his career, per PFF.

Weaknesses​

  • Can be a little too quick to open hips to route movement.
  • Allows unnecessary separation from off-man coverage.
  • Needs better eye balance and decisiveness from off coverage.
  • Loses some ground when it turns into a flat-out foot race.
  • Plays receiver’s hands instead of the ball with back to the action.
  • Arm tackler and slow to get rid of perimeter blockers.
Fourth Pick
Jaylin Lane

Overview​

Semi-versatile slot option with legitimate long speed and talent to add yardage with the ball in his hands. Lane can stretch defenses from the slot with his build-up speed and is a viable option in catch-and-run packages near the line of scrimmage. He gives too many clues as a route runner and needs to work on running repeatable, fluid routes as a pro. While he’s tough as a runner, he can’t muster the play strength or ball skills to win the contested-catch game. Lane’s best qualities give him a chance to stick on a roster, but he might need to earn his keep as a return man early on.

Strengths​

  • Build-up speed allows him to gain and maintain vertically.
  • Puts safeties on their heels with deep speed from the slot.
  • Capable of opening hips and reaching to make a catch on an off-target pass.
  • Good run-after-catch option on receiver screens and hitches.
  • Determined runner who breaks through arm tackles.
  • Fearless north-south mindset as a punt returner.

Weaknesses​

  • Below-average short-area footwork and suddenness.
  • Needs to work on salesmanship and efficiency of his routes.
  • Short, choppy strides hinder separation at the top of the route.
  • Allows defenders to play through him at the catch point.
  • Needs better feel for angles and working back to the throw.
6th Round Kain Madrano

POSITIVES
— Great athlete who earned a 9.83 RAS at the NFL combine. Solid length, too.
— Decent at reading the quarterback's eyes when playing zone coverage and has the movement skills to tighten throwing windows and take away reads from the quarterback.
— Has the athleticism to cover tight ends in man coverage.
— Plenty of speed to carry running backs and tight ends in man or take away the middle of the field when playing Tampa 2.
— Flashed decent instincts when on the playside of outside runs.

NEGATIVES
— Wiry build. Could afford to add some size and strength to avoid getting pushed around against the run.
— Subpar instincts versus inside runs. Hasn't shown the ability to crash downhill and attack gaps.
— Gets stuck on blocks, lacks the strength to stack and shed.
— Poor tackler, missed a lot of tackles last season because he lunges and doesn't bring his feet. Gives up extra yards after contact, as he doesn't have much force behind his pads.

7th Round Pick
Jacory Croskey Merritt

Overview​

Eligibility issues sidelined Croskey-Merritt for all but one game in 2024, but his skills were on full display at the East-West Shrine Bowl in January. He’s a quick processor with adequate size and impressive cut quickness to find yards in a crowded workspace. He has one-cut talent and the ability to break runs sharply across the grain when necessary. He finishes runs with purpose, too. He’ll be a 24-year-old rookie with below-average third-down value, but his talent and creativity pop quickly on tape and give him a chance to become a good RB2 at the next level.

Strengths​

  • Reads defenses to second level and quickly processes/responds.
  • Outstanding stop, cut and accelerate mechanism to elude in tight spaces.
  • Runs with block anticipation and a feel for cutting off of the blocker’s hip.
  • Able to snap off one-cut runs at crisp angles.
  • Delivers force into contact without losing base balance.
  • Highly competitive finishes squeeze every yard from the run.

Weaknesses​

  • Nearly a non-factor in the passing game during college career.
  • Finds heavy collisions more frequently than teams might desire.
  • Missed all but one game last season due to eligibility issues.
  • Will be a 24-year-old rookie at running back.
 
Last edited:
I'll admit my first reaction wasn't joy. Conerly rated well and was always one of the ones talked about, but I kept hearing how he needed to get stronger and was more of a guy who needed to be developed so my desire for a trade down and to fill the glaring need at edge and corner lessened my enthusiasm. However, at the start of the offseason (like I posted on Bluesky) my number one goal was to upgrade the trenches and this is a trench pick. Going from a Rivera line to a line with Tunsil, Coleman, Biadazz (sp), Cosmi, and Conerly in two years is (on paper) remarkable. We've potentially gone from a D to at least a B+. It will be interesting to see who wins the tackle/guard duel between Coleman and Conerly. Peters still left that door open in his presser yesterday and I thought that Coleman did quite well for a raw rookie with no training camp or offseason because of injury.
 
Meh. I thought we had addressed tackle fairly well. I do think having a high skill pocket aware mobile QB minimizes the need to use so many assets at tackle but understand I am likely 100% alone my opinion that JD can win behind a less than stellar line and that using first round assets on it was not a need. That we needed an edge far more. He seems a bit tall and light to be kicked inside. As a mere lowly peasant armchair fan, I concede to the opine of AP.

"If you knew the game, you'd be in it" - George McPhee
 
Meh. I thought we had addressed tackle fairly well. I do think having a high skill pocket aware mobile QB minimizes the need to use so many assets at tackle but understand I am likely 100% alone my opinion that JD can win behind a less than stellar line and that using first round assets on it was not a need. That we needed an edge far more. He seems a bit tall and light to be kicked inside. As a mere lowly peasant armchair fan, I concede to the opine of AP.

"If you knew the game, you'd be in it" - George McPhee
I think you're right in general, but I also think the Eagles/Chiefs game spooked them. Maholmes was helpless despite his slipperiness. So Daniels escapability while being a plus probably shouldn't be used as a crutch. I certainly would love to see Jayden running less and feeling more comfortable in going through his progressions. Mind you, if I were picking I'd still probably have traded down or picked edge, but I can't argue the logic.
 
My sole concern is that from a BPA perspective, it seems the consensus pick is Campbell who the stupid Eagles got. I don't see how we don't need a young, fast LB. The Eagles lost a great LB to injury in the playoffs last year and still won due primarily to their defense. I think sometimes that is forgotten somehow. I was looking forward to a pure BPA draft. According to AP, his chart had Conerly as BPA, which to me doesn't make total sense. I am not a draft expert, I rely on draft sources; it seems there is a rough consensus around Campbell and the Eagles draft board seems to agree. So, that is disturbing to me.

Years back, I was not a BPA person, but I really thought AP's FA strategy hinted we were going to go full BPA here, especially at this pick (29) where I think BPA has significant talent gaps. Again, that is why the Eagles threw a pick away to get Campbell. It's not solely about the Eagles though, it seems like there is a pretty good consensus on 29's BPA being Campbell. So, for me, that is a bit of a problem.
 
Last edited:
I don’t think you can ever go wrong beefing up the line. I also didn’t think they would address OT early, but I will never complain when they take an OL. That position was ignored in the draft for years by previous coaches and GMs. This front office is protecting their most important asset.
 
Some info on the newest Commander, courtesy of Dane Brugler's The Beast and the PFF 2025 Draft Guide


1745590931108.png



1745591012970.png



1745591088171.png



1745591107218.png



1745591128632.png
 
Cleaner, safer, needing to run less JD5 makes me happy.

Realizing this kid consistently beat the #3 pick in the draft who was taken by a division rival?

I am thrilled with this pick.
 
I have no idea how this will work out, but this guy has quick feet and good lateral movement off the snap, you can tell he's athletic.

We only have Tunstill for 2 years as of now so maybe a future switch to LT is something the team believes is a possibility. He looks good on both sides.
 
Last edited:
With the Conerly pick I had completely forgot about signing Nate Herbig....interested to see where he fits in, if nothing else a very solid backup at guard.
 
I confused Josh Connerly and Anthony Belton. So I am much happier when I realised my mistake. Dude is legit.
 
With the 2nd pick Washington selects CB Trey Amos

Overview​

Long press cornerback who proved he could make the jump from the Sun Belt to the SEC without a hitch. Amos can disrupt the release and plays with good short-area movement in man coverage. He can get a little lost at the top of the route and needs occasional safety nets over the top. He has twitchy feet to close and sees the action clearly from zone but can be hampered by indecisiveness, despite favorable instincts. Amos uses physicality and length to shrink the 50/50 odds in his favor. He can play in multiple coverage but is most consistent in zone. Amos needs to ramp up his run support and trust his eyes in space, but he has the goods to become a solid starting outside corner.

Strengths​

  • Possesses foot quickness and size to be a problem in press.
  • Plays with pro coverage agility and transition quickness.
  • Has body control and footwork needed to stay in phase versus NFL routes.
  • Twitchy burst and long arms help with catch disruption.
  • Plant-and-drive is sudden and without stall at the top.
  • Desired pacing, positioning and vision in Cover 3 looks.
  • Allowed sub-19 percent completion rate on throws of 20-plus air yards for his career, per PFF.

Weaknesses​

  • Can be a little too quick to open hips to route movement.
  • Allows unnecessary separation from off-man coverage.
  • Needs better eye balance and decisiveness from off coverage.
  • Loses some ground when it turns into a flat-out foot race.
  • Plays receiver’s hands instead of the ball with back to the action.
  • Arm tackler and slow to get rid of perimeter blockers.
 
I like this pick a lot. Sainristil is a player and I have hopes that Lattimore can come back, but we needed someone with length.
 
Washington is keeping pace with the Eagles, selecting late in each round and still coming up with highly rated guys that fall to them.

I agree with Peters in that both Conerly Jr and Amos profile as first round picks and the fact we were able to get both after pick 29 is a job well done.

When you have 5 picks and the GM says he had chances to move down but loved these players and stayed pat, he's really putting himself and the scouts on the line.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Help Users

You haven't joined any rooms.

    You haven't joined any rooms.
    Top