- Joined
- Apr 11, 2009
- Messages
- 55,812
- Reaction score
- 17,402
- Points
- 2,743
- Location
- Greensboro, NC
- Military Branch

- Alma Mater

Okay - but I think you are talking about two separate things. Whether a player pans out is one thing. Whether he was the right pick where he was drafted is another. And the other thing is, we can’t be sure with a given pick if it was a ‘need’ pick, a ‘BPA’ pick, or a combination of those two things. I get that with picks like the Mathis selection, it appears to be a ‘need’ pick, but we can’t know that for sure.
As far as Mathis goes, I think it’s very questionable right now whether he’ll pan out. Was he the right pick there? I think most of us would say no because we had greater needs AND (at least right now with limited data) he doesn’t appear to be a guy who is going to be a starter. Whether he was a need or BPA (in their judgment) I don’t know.
As far as Mathis goes, I think it’s very questionable right now whether he’ll pan out. Was he the right pick there? I think most of us would say no because we had greater needs AND (at least right now with limited data) he doesn’t appear to be a guy who is going to be a starter. Whether he was a need or BPA (in their judgment) I don’t know.

