Watched more Bailey, Love, Tate, Tyson, Downs -- IMO all likely going to be really good NFL players, Tyson the biggest grower for me in that mix. Love his head fakes and how he stems his routes, natural seperator. Bailey my #1 guy.
I watched more Lemon, too. I see he has some detractors on this thread. He physically doesn't look like the typical #1 WR. But i am doubling down on the idea if they trade down he'd be my #1 want. Just a quick seperator, glue hands, one of the better YAC guys in this group -- but among these WRs he's the dude who comes off as one who won't be denied, baller, it jumps out in a big way when watching him. I've watched a bunch of these WRs, still diving in, Lemon is the most fun watch so far. And you can see his intensity when the camera pans to him off the field -- he has that sort of old school Gary Clark look.
Among draft geeks I noticed Tate, Lemon, Tyson are interchangeable as to their #1 Wr, with Lemon usually the third because of being a slot. For me I got no issue with that, lol I hate to fall in line with consensus on these three but right now i am there with the consensus but the combine can be a game changer on this front. Only WR close to those three IMO is Boston.
All three are different flavors so it depends on what you want. Tate -- Devonte Smith-Adams hybrid IMO. Can make acrobatic catches, great body control, amazing hands, great blocker -- but he's not an all over the field kind of WR IMO to use a baseball analogy he's a doubles-home run hitter. He's a natural Z IMO.
Tyson is an all over the field type of WR. Stefon Diggs some JSN, quick seperator and in small space and on that front reminds me of Beckham. Tyson would easily be my #1 if he was a YAC guy and some say he is but he's not. I think he's an X who could replace Terry at some point.
Lemon -- hard comp for me, he's IMO a mix of Kupp, McConkey, JSN. Not exactly like anyone of them. To use a Washington example, Jamison Crowder at his peak but a better athlete, much more intense and better than Crowder at everything. But I bring up Crowder because at his peak was a quick seperator. He's a natural of course Y-slot WR. Super quick seperator in tight spaces like Tyson. But plays with a competitiveness and drive that is hard to miss that makes him come off to me like a gamer that's why I comp him some to McConkey. In a big game in the playoffs with everything on the line, I'd trust a big throw from Jayden to Lemon. You throw a quick screen and need the WR to dodge a defender and motor 5 yards to win the game -- am not trusting Boston or Tate or Tyson to do it, I am trusting Lemon.
Lemon is a smaller receiver but separates well and profiles as a slot demon in the NFL.
www.pff.com
At 5-foot-11 and 195 pounds, Lemon is on the smaller side. I have him categorized as a slot receiver, not just because he played 354 snaps in the slot compared to just 54 out wide in 2024, but also due to how he wins and his strengths. Lemon is lightning quick. He has short strides but moves his legs like pistons in an engine, firing out of his stance to eat up cushion in coverage or getting vertical before defenders can adjust.
He is also a nuanced and technical route runner, despite being just a true junior entering 2025. He knows how to set up defenders against their leverage and can find soft spots against zone by tempoing his speed at different points in his route. Lemon's
PFF Game Athleticism Score in 2024 ranked just above the 95th percentile, with five plays where he topped 20 mph. But more telling than his top speed is his play speed, evidenced by his 100 plays where he was clocked between 15-20 mph. Despite facing press on only 85 of his 262 receiving snaps in 2024, he already has a good baseline of different releases versus press coverage. And as a run blocker, he is feisty and strong for his body type.
Lemon also fares well in PFF's stable metrics, which are predictive of success from year to year. In other words, if a player ranks highly in a stable metric in college, they have a strong chance of doing so in the NFL, even with a built-in dip in rate because of the bump in talent. The opposite is true, too.
He placed in the 87th percentile in separation rate (83.6%) and ranked in the 65th percentile in separation rate against single coverage (63.3%) in 2024. His 3.03 yards per route run — a good way to look at per-play production — slotted him into the 89th percentile.
Makai Lemon's 2024 Stable Metric Ranks
| Stable Metric | Percentile Among WRs |
| PFF Receiving Grade | 94th |
| PFF Receiving Grade vs. Single Coverage | 94th |
| PFF Receiving Grade vs. Zone, Underneath, Top | 72nd |
| Separation Rate | 87th |
| Separation Rate vs. Single Coverage | 65th |
| Yards per Route Run | 89th |
| Average Depth of Target | 27th |
| Yards After the Catch per Reception | 81st |
When we think of WR1-caliber prospects in a draft class, big-bodied “X” receivers often come to mind. That's true for most drafts. But just like in 2023 when Jaxson Smith-Njigba was WR1, there are outliers. The name of the game is getting open, and Lemon does that at a high level and possesses the traits to continue to do so in the NFL.