What to do about the trenches?

As far as how much of an overhaul the OL needs based on the stats posted a few posts ago, and what we 'saw' in 2024, I would say that regardless of what you think about the guys who were 'starters', our depth was inadequate. Late in the season, we saw that the guys we ended up relying on just didn't have the physicality to be effective stand-ins and frequently got abused and dominated. If nothing else, we have got to improve the depth and quality of reserves on the OL.
Yes! It's probably an "And" situation. We need better starters AND we need to improve our depth. I almost think the latter more important than the former.
 
I think after seeing Philly push our lines around like a shopping cart in Sams Club, it's pretty clear where the priority starts.
And that's where it starts and ends: closing the wide gap with Philly.
 
I thought Coleman's size and measurables were great for left tackle, especially his quickness and basketball agility, but his rawness and lack of game experience was the big drawback? That the reason why "experts" wanted to move him inside was to shield him from that inexperience as tackles is a harder position to learn.

In any case, I am hopeful he continues to grow and cements the position. The coaches will be the final arbiter of that though if Coleman works hard he will have a powerful voice in the argument. I think his play provided cases in both directions.

I am relying pretty heavily on Logan Paulson's take, but his athleticism and size is fine for LT, its his stiff hips and lack of bend that will probably always limit his pass blocking there. You want to pass block with a vertical torso so that you center of gravity is always on your feet. But if guys have stiff hips they are going to bend when they reach out to engage the pass rusher and that is going to move their center of gravity and they are not going to have the same balance. That means they will be at risk of overcommitting and being susceptible to counter moves or just being wrong in their over commitment. Because you are pass blocking in less space that matters less in pass blocking for Guards. But his athleticism is good and that is why he should be able to develop into a good run blocker (whether that be at Guard or Tackle) and his size is fine for both Tackle or Guard. The question is will his stiff hips limit his ceiling at Tackle.
 
Last edited:
If we draft an OT at 29 he needs to be starter ready and not raw. We don't have time to coach em up - we are competing. Now.

My preference for edge aside, I do like 1st rounders to be all down players. OL WR RB FS... We have needs all over the place. Improvements on the OL/Depth is just one area of need.
 
Outside of Center, there isn't one sure thing at this point along our offensive line entering 2025. That might sound a bit harsh, but I think it is a lot closer to reality than many might want to believe.

Cosmi, while rock solid at RG, is going to be out for a while with a serious injury. I don't think you can just automatically assume he returns to the level he played at this past year.

Allegretti at LG, to me, is better suited as your top interior depth piece off the bench, much like he did in KC. It was a bit of a gamble thrusting him into a starting role last year after limited starts in his career up until the start of '24.

Coleman had a promising rookie year, but also experienced his shared of struggles at LT. Can we assume he is just going to potentially kick inside and adjust well? If he stays at LT, will he continue to ascend? I don't think that '24 leaves you beaming with confidence that he is locking down LT for the next ten years.

Wylie at RT...that is an obvious hole that needs to be addressed.

Overall, ideally, you acquire a very solid Tackle on either the left or right side at the very least. If Coleman does not kick inside, you need two starting quality guards and have Allegretti serve as your top option off the bench. That puts you on the path to sustain long term playoff success year over year.
 
If we draft an OT at 29 he needs to be starter ready and not raw. We don't have time to coach em up - we are competing. Now.

My preference for edge aside, I do like 1st rounders to be all down players. OL WR RB FS... We have needs all over the place. Improvements on the OL/Depth is just one area of need.

Edge is one of the deeper positions in this draft and there will probably be decent value there at 29 so that is definitely a possibility. You really cannot go wrong drafting a pass rusher.

My ideal scenario is you have Membou or Connerly available at 29 and can get decent value at OT at 29. Then you go D-Line (probably Edge in round 2) and RB in 3. That is like an ideal scenario. The reason I like a Tackle in the first round is I have seen draft position charts for Tackle and it is just so hard to get Tackle value on day 3. It absolutely happens, but it happens less than at other positions like OG or DT or CB, WR, et cetera.

More realistically there may not be any value available at Tackle at 29 and the best play is D-Line or CB at 29.
 
I'm a firm believer that you have to "beat them from the inside out". We have so many holes I would like to see a repeat of what we did last year by adding one OL and one DL from the draft.

1739637614692.png
 
I am relying pretty heavily on Logan Paulson's take, but his athleticism and size is fine for LT, its his stiff hips and lack of bend that will probably always limit his pass blocking there. You want to pass block with a vertical torso so that you center of gravity is always on your feet. But if guys have stiff hips they are going to bend when they reach out to engage the pass rusher and that is going to move their center of gravity and they are not going to have the same balance. That means they will be at risk of overcommitting and being susceptible to counter moves or just being wrong in their over commitment. Because you are pass blocking in less space that matters less in pass blocking for Guards. But his athleticism is good and that is why he should be able to develop into a good run blocker (whether that be at Guard or Tackle) and his size is fine for both Tackle or Guard. The question is will his stiff hips limit his ceiling at Tackle.

Sounds like Coleman needs to take ballet lessons in the offseason. And that’s not a joke.
 
D-Line PFF Grades

Team Grades
Pass Rush 69 (15th)
Run Defense 49.6 (29th)

Dorrence Armstrong Overall Grade 65.3/Snaps 747/Pass Rush 78/Run Defense 41.4
Donte Fowler Overall Grade 60.5/Snaps 642/Pass Rush 63.6/Run Defense 52.3
Jalyn Holmes Overall Grade 56.5/Snaps 234/Pass Rush 54.8/Run Defense 61.6
Jonathan Allen Overall Grade 56.0/Snaps 421/Pass Rush 68.5/Run Defense 42.2
Sheldon Day Overall Grade 54.7Snaps 339/Pass Rush 52.4/Run Defense 56.2
Javonte Jean Baptiste Overall Grade52.9/Snaps 248/Pass Rush 50/Run Defense 58.3
Jer'Zhan Newton Overall Grade 52.7/Snaps 586/Pass Rush 62.7/Run Defense 46.3
Daron Payne Overall Grade 51.8/Snaps 586/Pass Rush 62.7/Run Defense 46.3
Clellin Ferrell Overall Grade 51.7/Snaps 443Pass Rush 58.8/Run Defense 55
Phildarian Mathis Overall Grade 32.3/Snaps 257/Pass Rush 55.7/Run Defense 29
 
Offense- If we can get a good LT, move Coleman to RT, move Wylie inside or if we cut him draft or sign a good FA guard, then we can have Lucas as a solid back up at tackle and Nick Allegretti as a solid back up at guard and center. I need to put some thought into the Defensive line situation.

p.s. does anyone know a good Washington Wizard forum. It looks like they finally figured it out on how to build a competitive team. Wish they are doing what they are doing now years ago.
 
I thought Coleman's size and measurables were great for left tackle, especially his quickness and basketball agility, but his rawness and lack of game experience was the big drawback? That the reason why "experts" wanted to move him inside was to shield him from that inexperience as tackles is a harder position to learn.

In any case, I am hopeful he continues to grow and cements the position. The coaches will be the final arbiter of that though if Coleman works hard he will have a powerful voice in the argument. I think his play provided cases in both directions.

Keep drafting tackles until either...

a) one is better than Coleman, and slide him to either RT or guard

b) Coleman proves that he's a really good tackle

We are multiple linemen away from having the line we need, so just keep trying to add elite tackles, and then adjust the starting 5 to get the best talent in the field.
 
In terms of order of operations, I’ve got:
1) Re-sign Lucas prior to FA.
2) Look hard at both OT and G in FA.
3) Look at OT, and G and/or G/Cs in the draft… even if you address the spots in FA.
4) If you land a FA OT, or a rookie OT that looks promising, and you add a player to the interior, cut Wylie.
5) Revisit FA for depth if necessary.

I recall Keim (I think?) saying the staff liked Good-Jones (G), who landed on the PS. So at a minimum, once you sign Lucas, you have a (relatively) passable trio of tackles, and Paul/Good-Jones competing for RG/depth. Not ideal, but it’s a baseline. I think the minimum end result should be adding a quality starter and a good depth/competition piece.

For dline, I think the minimum is two FA edges at the Fowler/Ferrell level or better.
Would like to sign a DT. High end starter might be a tough ask, but maybe a quality older guy on a short term deal.
I expect to use our 1st or 2nd on dline as well.

Outside of the parameters of the thread, but signing a good corner could be a significant help for the dline, both in terms of providing better coverage for blitzing, and allowing us to devote another guy to the box.
In a similar vein, a dangerous weapon or two on offense could help open up the ground game.
 
Trenches win the war. Been that way forever
 
Jayden hid many issues with the OLINE. If you take Jayden out of the running game the team drops to middle of the pack in running
And that’s probably generous, even if the numbers stack up that way. I was thinking about this the other day… we have Anthony Lynn as the RB coach and Run game coordinator, after that, it’s Bobby Johnson as a run game guy, if you can put him in that bucket. In the pass game, you have Kliff, Tavita and Blouth (all ex-qbs?) and Brian Johnson. Point being, it feels like we could use another advocate (and “guru”) for the run game.
 
I think you try and sign a tackle (probably RT who can also play guard), and then you draft someone who falls into your lap. Membou or Conerly would be good in that regard. If they come in and play at a high level at LT, great, slide Coleman inside. If not, let Coleman stay outside and slide new pick inside. If we pick later than the 1st for OT, then we probably slide them inside anyway.

For opening day, only 2 players are set, Coleman, somewhere between LT and LG, and Biadasz at C. Cosmi will come back eventually but obviously is not available right now. Adding a tackle in FA, then drafting one, can hopefully get us to 4 solid guys, and we can hopefully find a nice fill-in for Cosmi until he returns.

Insofar as DLine is concerned, that one is gonna take some doing. If I had to guess, we might be swapping Allen for Osa at DT, and I think Newton pleasantly surprises us. I'd still love to add a guy like Poona Ford who excels against the run, but if you're paying Osa and Payne, there's some limits we'll be up against.

Generally speaking our pass rush was good, not great, and our run D was poor. Obviously if we end up with Myles Garrett that answers a lot of questions, but the more I think about it, the more likely it is the 2nd round might be the sweet spot for an edge guy. First round might drop a great player to us, like Mike Green, but very decent chance it won't, in which case OL might be the play there. But there's a lot of depth at the top, there's probably 10ish dudes worthy of 1st or 2nd round picks, so odds are good one of them makes it to 61. Heck, some of them may make it to 79.

DT depth is also insane. I *could* see a DT in the first 3 rounds, but I could also see us grabbing a guy at 148 or later bc of the class depth, or maybe trading like a 2026 3rd to get a 4th round pick and snag someone who fell who we had a high grade on.
 
Great writeup from Hogs Haven. Give it a read. From this article: https://www.hogshaven.com/2025/2/8/...mmanders-offensive-line-in-the-2025-offseason


New 2025 Offensive Line:

LT - Alaric Jackson (FA)

LG - Brandon Coleman

C - Tyler Biadasz

RG - Sam Cosmi (Andrew Wylie as a place-holder as needed)

RT - Emery Jones (NFL Draft Rd 2)

Backup G - Nick Allegretti

Swing OT - Andrew Wylie


The Commanders were poor in both run blocking and pass protection in 2024. Signing a veteran like Alaric Jackson will help eliminate two problems. He will lock down the left side for the foreseeable future and it allows the young, athletic Coleman to kick inside to guard, completely changing the dynamics on the left side. Biadasz will continue to hold down center and hopefully Cosmi can return from injury early in the season and provide stability at right guard. If Cosmi misses some games, Wylie can kick inside to guard until he’s ready to return. The powerful rookie Emery Jones takes over as the team’s right tackle, giving Washington two legitimate bookends to help keep Jayden Daniels upright and open up holes for our running backs. Allegretti and Wylie will be valuable veteran backups. There will also be some depth signings and draft picks to help fill out the 53-man roster.

Now I do feel we need an upgrade at running back - someone with better vision and burst will help the o-line look that much better. That, however, will be saved for another article.


Maybe at RT I'd replace Emery Jones with Aireontae Ersery from Minnesota.
 
Is Alaric Jackson really that good though? ESPN has him ranked as the #40 Free Agent, which is lower than Chase Young and Justin Fields.

40. Alaric Jackson, OT

Best team fit: New England Patriots

We've already matched a few players to New England, but the Patriots have the most cap space in the NFL and can continue to spend by adding Jackson to play left tackle. With his 6-7, 345-pound frame, Jackson has the play strength to anchor against power off the edge, and he understands how to win with positioning. His experience (35 career starts) would be great in New England as the team builds up front to protect quarterback Drake Maye.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Help Users

You haven't joined any rooms.

    You haven't joined any rooms.
    Top