Commander Wraith
The 1st Round Pick
I generally agree with your take here. If Terry goes down, that’s likely a major problem for the offense. Chig (and the other TEs) and White (and the other backs) don’t look to be such major upgrades that will paper over the receiver concerns. And asking Blough to be a good (let alone great) play caller off the bat - particularly one that can overcome an apparent lack of high end personnel - isn’t practical.My issue with Finlay, who I like, and some of the others is that they're pointing to things that almost every team has as if somehow its unique to Washington or is special here. Yes, Washington has running backs who can catch the ball. So do a lot of teams. Yes, they have pass-catching tight ends. Again, so do a lot of teams—and in many cases, those teams have players with much stronger resumes than ours.
Then there's the "Blough will scheme it up" argument, which honestly makes me cringe. It's becoming the default explanation from some in the local media for why the receiver room isn't a concern. Grant Paulsen went there on a recent podcast, even while acknowledging that Sean McVay—Keim has said he heard the same thing—admitted he struggled as a first-year play caller and really took a leap in Year 2.
So Grant, who I also like, is essentially saying Blough is going to have rookie growing pains while simultaneously treating him as the secret weapon that's going to make this receiver group work. That's a lot of rationalizing for me.
Look, maybe all of the best-case scenarios happen. Maybe Ben Sinnott turns into a star. Maybe Luke McCaffrey develops into the kind of player his brother became. Maybe Blough breaks the mold and is an outstanding play caller right away. Maybe Rachaad White becomes prime Austin Ekeler as a receiving back.
Could all of that happen? Sure. I don't know.
What I do know is that's a whole lot of maybes. If you're trying to build a legitimate contender, you don't want your offense resting on that many optimistic projections.
Even Keim, who's become more supportive of the offseason moves, has repeatedly said this roster has a major problem if Terry McLaurin gets hurt because there's no true No. 2 receiver to step into that role. To me, that's the biggest issue of all. Every team would miss its No. 1 receiver. But I think Washington would be hurt far more than most because there's no proven player behind Terry capable of carrying that load. That's the risk I've had a hard time getting past.
lol, sign Diggs and I endorse everything. But its tough for me to look at this team playing with this tough schedule and thinking stuff like wow will Blough dazzle and or yeah our Z isn't getting open but hey we can throw to Racaad White try to stop that. Or pretend Zach Ertz never existed and go wow Jayden now has a TE as his 2nd target how novel.
Where I differ is that I don’t know that we need Luke/Sinnott/White/Blough/etc to be stars. It’s almost certainly going to be a “by committee” venture. What we need from our pass catchers is quality run blocking, to occasionally run routes that clear out defenders, and to sell run blocking on PA (and then take advantage when the ball occasionally comes their way).
Perhaps the more crucial factor is what we need from the scheme - for guys to be used to their strengths:
Williams and Lane: to separate, find holes in zones, run choice routes and routes to pull defenders out of the run game.
Dyami and Luke: wr screens, occasional deep shots, plus run blocking with short/intermediate routes off PA
Chig/Sinnott: run away from backers, sell PA, not lose to backers/safeties (and occasionally corners) in the run game
Terry: to take advantage of getting moved around and (continue) to win on deep shots
Bates: block his face off, sell PA on occasional TE leaks
White: continue to be a quality pass catcher and not be a bum when he’s handed the ball
Jefferson: be that chain mover ala Ertz
Burks is the tricky one. I’d probably go with run block and sell PA.
Bill is kind of an exception IMO. He’s the one (aside from Lane not dropping the ball) that needs to make strides with his weaknesses (vs being used to his strengths) - to take what is blocked, not put the ball on the ground, and to make some strides in pass pro.
Regarding Blough, I think the hope is about the scheme vs the play calling. A scheme that makes life easier on the oline via more called runs and lots of PA, and that makes life easier on the pass catchers by not relying as heavily on winning 1 on 1 matchups. It’ll put more on Jayden’s plate, but at this point, I feel comfortable in him being able to handle it. I also think that in terms of play calling, while I expect it will almost certainly come with some struggles, I wonder if Blough may have a bit of an advantage over someone like McVay due to his time at qb in both the college and pros, and playing under multiple coaches/offenses.
Now, with all of that said, there is still an element of relying on hope/potential, and I’m with you in that I’d feel a lot more comfortable if we had another proven pass catcher. I also agree with an opinion of yours that you’ve expressed in other posts (I’m paraphrasing here) that while things could work and we could have a pretty good offense (primarily because of Jayden)… we should be shooting for the Super Bowl, not just pretty good. Adding someone like Diggs makes that aim more attainable.
