I wouldn't be surprised either. It feels very Peters like. I like what he's done in FA. But he hasn't earned my trust on the WR spot -- his leaps of faith have rarely worked thus far.
I mean, what more did you want him to do? If you believe the reporting he offered Pierce more money than the Colts, but Pierce wanted to stay in Indy, and he offered Doubs as much money as the Pats, and he went to New England.
In my opinion, you would have a point if he clearly didn't see that there was a problem and AGGRESSIVELY tried to address it as best as possible. He took shots at the two top WRs who were available. It didn't work, but he went after what was there.
And I think it's somewhat unfair to say his leaps of faith have rarely worked in the WR. They basically all worked in 2024: Noah Brown as a pickup after cutdowns, OZ and to a lesser extent, retaining DBrown. Sure, they could have added somebody else in FA in 2024, but they got good production from everybody they signed. I'd say all of those leaps of faith worked out nicely.
2025, he made mistakes. You attribute it to arrogance, and you've been absolutely steadfast on that stance absent any reporting that I've seen to support the opinion. Which is fine, but I think it's also clouding your judgement a little at this point.
2024, they made some really good additions. 2025, he made 2 moves which in conjunction were a mistake:
a. Trading for Deebo, who is a "move around" piece, not a WR2 outside guy
b. Signing Noah Brown as the defacto starting outside WR opposite McLaurin.
The idea was Terry + Deebo + NBrown would give them the ability to spread the field vertically, both Brown and McLaurin did that very well in 2024, and horizontally, which was Deebo's specialty. But what it also did is it loaded the WR room with 4 locked in players, because McCaffery was just drafted. So any backup level player was competing for the 5th spot assuming they didn't draft anybody. If they signed a true upgrade to Noah Brown, that's different, but to get the #5 guy, that's a challenge at that point. So you saw all the old reclamation projects and never has beens come in here.
The whole thing was a mistake. If they had not traded for Deebo, but had signed Brown, then they could have done some things, or if they hadn't signed Noah Brown, they could have done some things. Together, it was a big mistake.
In 2026, he seemingly learned from it, attacked the top of the market aggressively. When it didn't work, he was forced to plan B, and pretty quickly signed additional depth guys in Van Jefferson and Diyami Brown, both of which can play a bit. I'm absolutely convinced they will sign another starter somehow. Whether that's Aiyuk, draft pick, Deebo, any 2 of those or all three of those options. I doubt all three, but at least one is going to happen. And I wouldn't be surprised if 2 happen, as in Aiyuk/Deebo + Draft pick.
I'm sure I'm going to get a 3 page rebuttal, but I'll be honest, I really liked seeing Peters acknowledge through actions his mistake by going for the top of the market. He doesn't have to say that he knew there was a problem, he showed us he knew there was a problem. And to me that shows he's smart and humble enough to admit he made a mistake and learn from it.
And that's what leads me to believe they're not done yet. I don't think they want a repeat of 2025. They had a front row seat for it. They've already tried to be very different. They have to change tactics because plan A of Pierce didn't work even through they offered more money. So they've already started the pivot. There's not much more they can do immediately, unless they re-sign Deebo. So we wait.