Only thing about putting Downs in that role is that we are asking a lot out of a rookie no matter how smart he is. There’s have to be a lot of things to align damn near perfect for him to be able to control the entire defense communication wise day one.
Might be. Might be also for a linebacker. Smart veterans might be the better road.
Downs though specifically is supposedly a savant through the roof as far as understanding a scheme, dissecting opponent's offenses, etc.
Ohio State's Caleb Downs isn’t just talented — he’s relentless in dissecting greatness itself, and it’s this obsession that has carried him to where he is today.
www.foxsports.com
Upon returning home one afternoon, Caleb vaulted into a two-week binge of internet videos and marathon practice sessions until he, too, could conquer the cube. He performed the puzzle faster and faster with each passing day, dazzling his brother and sister by once completing it in 60 seconds. "It was crazy," Tanya told me. And then once that particular task had been perfected, Caleb put down the Rubik’s Cube and shifted to his next fixation.
"Some things just catch his eye," Gary told me, "and all of a sudden he wants to know about it and wants to master it."
elying solely on instincts and athleticism, as Caleb had done for most of his freshman and sophomore seasons, would only take him so far.
That’s when father and son devised a plan inspired by the following words: "Put before your eyes that which you want to be," meaning if Caleb wanted to embody the top-ranked safety in the country, he needed to become an expert on players who fit that mold. His new list of study subjects included Ed Reed, Sean Taylor, Brian Dawkins,
Troy Polamalu, Ronnie Lott and Eric Berry, a handful of the best safeties in NFL history. Caleb pored over highlight tapes, interview footage, feature stories and documentaries — anything and everything from which he might glean bits of what made those players into stars.
"What types of plays they were making, what type of work ethic do they have, what did they stand for, who these people were to be considered great, to be considered the top in their field, elite in that category," Caleb told me. "I mean, that’s how I saw myself."
By then, Caleb was already an active participant in devising game plans and scheming up in-game adjustments at Mill Creek, where head coach Josh Lovelady willingly leaned on him for input. The collaborative nature of that relationship was exactly what Gary had hoped for when deciding where his younger son should attend high school. He had pushed aside one program the family liked because, as Gary told me, "I didn’t want him to be under a coach that would be offended by Caleb; some coaches aren’t used to players having any ideas." And for years, Caleb had grown accustomed to working in tandem with his youth coach, Pat Mullins, who made a habit of sending him tape and asking for feedback on certain teams or individuals.
"You’re not the producer or the director," Gary told me, "but you’re acting. And having a director or producer that is willing to take, you know, some inference from you [is huge]. I think in his role as a player, being around the right coaches that recognized [Caleb’s] ability to see football was really important."
Charles Kelly, who became Caleb’s primary recruiter at Alabama, told me he only needed to see four plays to identify the best prospect on the field when he watched Mill Creek live for the first time, so obvious was the talent wearing the No. 2 jersey. Later that evening, Caleb called Kelly to thank him for making the 250-mile trip from Tuscaloosa. Their conversation lasted nearly three hours as the coach drove from Douglasville, Georgia, back to the Crimson Tide’s campus, during which time Caleb lobbed question after question regarding high-level football strategy. They never made it to another topic.
But even when Caleb wanted to talk about football, he wasn’t always talking about football — not in a traditional sense with X’s and O’s and defensive philosophy. He often asked Kelly to describe some of the best defensive backs he’d ever coached, like Brian Branch at Alabama (2020-22) and Derwin James at Florida State (2015-17), eager to learn about what those players did
off the field in preparation for games. They went deep on topics like strength and conditioning, nutrition and how the business world worked, how football players could market themselves in college and beyond. The intellectual nature of their relationship reminded Kelly of something his mother used to tell him growing up: "The more books you read," she told him, "the more you increase your intelligence." And by then, Caleb was already an avid reader.
"He would just say [things like],
How is this guy successful?" Charlie Strong, a defensive analyst with the Crimson Tide when Downs was at Alabama and now the defensive line coach for the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, told me. "And it wasn’t just football players. It was about people outside of football.
What do I have to do to be like this person?"
And there was, perhaps, no person who Caleb wanted to be like more than Saban, arguably the greatest coach in college football history with seven national championships and a dynastical run at Alabama until his retirement following the 2023 season. A huge portion of Saban’s messaging to his teams, Kelly told me, was about success being the product of myriad small decisions that are made every day. To someone as regimented and goal-oriented as Caleb, who arrived in the weight room promptly at 6 a.m. each day, those words seemed to validate the way he’d already been living his life.
So Caleb planted himself by Saban’s side during every defensive backs meeting, which he always led given his background with that position. Caleb could ask any question he wanted, as many questions as he wanted, and Saban delighted in having such an inquisitive pupil with an advanced football mind. The two remain in close contact to this day.
"He was the reason Caleb went to Alabama," Tanya told me. "On all the visits we went to, when we would sit and talk with Coach Saban, it was like Caleb was in a trance listening to him, soaking in all of the advice he was giving.
"All of his teammates, they would joke and say that Caleb was like Coach Saban more than anybody else on the team."
Just two obsessive peas in a pod.