Just tough news and really disappointing that DQ couldn't figure out that he had bad coaching going on under him. Process over results, it's key - basically looking at last year and saying, "hey we made the NFCCG, now we just need to change a few things" - from fans, that's fine.
From your HC? He needs to see how Donatell is not doing well. It needs to be something he can see, because frankly, the signs were there last year. Multiple DBs failing to reach potential, all showing similar issues in technique.
It just didn't have the right look even from our vantage point. I feel DQ could have figured it out, and yet here we are, with a wasted year. Those are expensive mistakes.
I find it tricky to isolate certain things in terms of this defense, particularly personnel vs scheme vs play calling vs position coaching. I think we tend to look for the most logical answers we can with what little info we have. Wagner struggling - he’s lost a step. Sainristil looking bad in the slot - he must be better suited outside. Quan must not be what we thought he was. For Luvu - it must be that he’s being used differently. Lattimore looks terrible - injuries have taken their toll and/or he’s lost his confidence. And so on. That applies to coaching as well - last year, it could be argued that Whitt didn’t have quality corners, our DEs weren’t great, Fowler couldn’t set the edge, etc. Not saying we are/were wrong on those things, just that it’s tough because of all the nuance. Plus our takes change as new info comes out.
Like (essentially) getting complaints about the scheme from Wagner and Sainristil. I mean, it’s not Wagner’s fault he got put in man vs Bijon Robinson. And how much do we put on the corners when we’re changing up the scheme we practiced all offseason, when they don’t have safety help, or when we need them to help vs the run game because of light boxes. It just gets difficult to dissect.
Same applies to Donatell. Quan looked fine last year. Sainristil looked pretty good outside last year. Amos looked good this year. I think Reeves has stepped up. So how much is on him vs scheme/play calling/personnel?
To your point, hopefully DQ has a much better pulse on things and can solve any coaching issues while also helping Peters fix personnel problems.
Agree.
If I had to nail the main mistake for Quinn and Peters
A. Quinn -- hiring a buddy to run the defense and watch it fall apart. The repercussions go beyond a bad unit -- discarding good players, their own players regressing. It's a total debacle.
B. Peters -- basically leaving no depth at WR. Yes he strengthened the O line. But basically trusted the Z spot to Noah Brown who can never stay healthy -- that's bad enough but the kicker is he had no net behind him or the X Wr.
I struggle with the wr piece. I’m assuming the thinking went something like - Deebo is an upgrade from (and a great fit for Kliff’s scheme), Brown, Luke (who’s got very similar metrics to Dyami) and Deebo can all play outside, and then Luke and Lane can backup Deebo in the slot. So then they ‘just’ needed another layer of insurance as a 6th receiver. So they have a competition between Moore, Martin, Gallup, and other UDFAs.
Maybe I’m being too generous here, but I think on paper that looked like an upgrade from last year. Even more so if McCaffrey improved and/or if Lane looked the part. Really bad luck wrt Wr injuries, coupled with oline growing pains and Daniels’ injuries have created a near perfect storm of a disaster. That’s not me absolving Peters, I just things look far worse due to surrounding factors. Similar to the defensive problems in a way.