Same In for Same Out for DC Area Sports Teams: It Is In The Stars

Man cannot live by Redskins alone


The All-Time Great
Jul 19, 2009
Reaction score
Bethesda Md

Much has been made of the DC sports 'curse' in regards to the Caps and Nats.

After several years of watching this melodrama playing out, my observation is that it was all predictable.


Because you had two talented teams in the Caps and Nats that had consistently underachieved in the postseason and the response of BOTH management groups was to bring in Managers and Coaches that had themselves consistently failed to get their competitive teams to advance in the postseason.

Barry Trotz had been a plus .550 coach in Nashville but never got beyond the second round of the playoffs.

Dusty Baker in over 20 years as Manager in the majors, only ONCE has taken a team to the World Series, in 2002, losing to the Anaheim Angles.

His 97 win Reds team a couple of years ago was an early flameout in the postseason.

So, we bring coaches that have had trouble climbing the mountain together with players that have had trouble climbing the mountain and we somehow expect that combination to result in end game success?

It just doesn't make any sense.

The last two Nationals managers were Williams and Baker.

The last two Capitals coaches were Oates and Trotz.

What do they ALL have in common?

Not a championship won by anyone in the group.

Williams and Oates were rookie coaches that were clearly in over their heads and were soon gone as marquee players ended up going to management to complain about them.

Want to change the trend and put these teams on the right course while the core players are still here and young enough to compete?

Get better leadership. Be willing to pay for it too.

Paying the players but going cheap on the 'head' of the team (ie the coaches) is not a smart move.

In today's sports leagues, you get 1 or 2 star players and a star manager and that together with merely solid supporting players is often enough to win a championship.

If the Nationals don't come back from the current 1-2 deficit and win this series, Baker needs to go.

I already thought Trotz needed to go after the Caps had rebounded from 3-1 to force a Game 7 at home against Pittsburgh only to lay a very ugly egg on home ice.


Staff member
Apr 11, 2009
Reaction score
Greensboro, NC

Marine Corps Virginia

That sounds dead, spot, on Bulldog. I've tried to follow and embrace the other DC teams. I certainly watch any time one of them makes the playoffs. But I cannot commit. Frankly, it has taken every bit of my patience and reason to keep my Redskins fandom burning through the ups and downs of the past 20 years. I just can't voluntarily take on more pain and suffering in the name of DC sports.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Private conversations
Help Users
    You haven't joined any rooms.
    Chat 0