Rymanofthenorth
BGObsessed
- Joined
- Nov 17, 2010
- Messages
- 5,705
- Reaction score
- 108
- Points
- 193
- Alma Mater

Serv, given that we are staying with the 3-4 despite again drafting a majority of 4-3 players, I have started wondering if perhaps the entire switch to the 3-4 was to drop games without appearing to drop them on purpose. Dropping games on purpose is taboo, but.....
It sounds rather conspiracy theoryish I know, but bear with me, Shanny took over a team that was not as talent poor as it appeared, but the cupboard for long term success was literally bare it was aging talent and the majority on defence, he could have made perhaps one short run in a playoff maybe 2, but doubtful that we would have won. Building a playoff roster requires resources, and the bulk of those resources come in the early rounds, and the earlier your pick, the more likely the chance of picking a stud player. By destroying the defence, he made it very unlikely that anyone would think we were a superbowl or even playoff calibre team and bought himself at least an extra season. a season to insert his systems, get the majority of his guys trained up in his style of offence and more importantly GET HIS GUYS in place.
Shanny is not a defencive genius, but aside from a tendency to force his system a bit, he has also never made a mistake on par with the defensive debacle last season. it will go down as one of the hugest drops in modern football. Usually he is very astute in his judgements of talent on either side of the ball and he has a huge ego that would seem to demand that he get the best team possible on the field. The only way I could see him failing so abjectly is if he had a plan in place that required such a failure early on in order for him to have a massive success later on. thats what I am banking on. some of the moves early on were schizophrenic, signing aging linemen and a QB but then getting rid of aging guys who still could at least play a little bit but replacing them with other old guys who cost less and had no fan investment. then drafting a LT but then waiting until late in the season to start playing younger guys?
all this leads me to the answer to your question about Beck, with Beck he has no pressure, everyone knows there are no good QB's in free agency this year, everyone knows how bad our defence is likely to be, nobody thinks with beck that we will make a sudden turnaround and nobody will be too upset when we win less games this year than last, BECAUSE WE NOW EXPECT IT. If he starts Grossman, Rexy will have a few games that make you wonder why he isnt a HOF QB, and we will wonder why he doesnt have a better cast around him , because if he did, we should be a solid team, suddenly people will ask " its almost year 3, why arent we far better than this we look good in flashes" whereas Beck will maybe flash once in a while and we will say " man, what could this team do with a good QB I cant wait until we draft one and we see what he can do with this team in this system." If by some miracle he played even decently Shannahan recovers some of his lost shine because he scooped a decent QB off the scrap pile. even now some of the dumber fans are saying " its not shannys fault the defence sucks its all on haslett" this season when we are losing and losing big, we will be doing it while hoping that there is light at the end of the tunnel, and I will be saying " bravo Shannahan, well played"
It sounds rather conspiracy theoryish I know, but bear with me, Shanny took over a team that was not as talent poor as it appeared, but the cupboard for long term success was literally bare it was aging talent and the majority on defence, he could have made perhaps one short run in a playoff maybe 2, but doubtful that we would have won. Building a playoff roster requires resources, and the bulk of those resources come in the early rounds, and the earlier your pick, the more likely the chance of picking a stud player. By destroying the defence, he made it very unlikely that anyone would think we were a superbowl or even playoff calibre team and bought himself at least an extra season. a season to insert his systems, get the majority of his guys trained up in his style of offence and more importantly GET HIS GUYS in place.
Shanny is not a defencive genius, but aside from a tendency to force his system a bit, he has also never made a mistake on par with the defensive debacle last season. it will go down as one of the hugest drops in modern football. Usually he is very astute in his judgements of talent on either side of the ball and he has a huge ego that would seem to demand that he get the best team possible on the field. The only way I could see him failing so abjectly is if he had a plan in place that required such a failure early on in order for him to have a massive success later on. thats what I am banking on. some of the moves early on were schizophrenic, signing aging linemen and a QB but then getting rid of aging guys who still could at least play a little bit but replacing them with other old guys who cost less and had no fan investment. then drafting a LT but then waiting until late in the season to start playing younger guys?
all this leads me to the answer to your question about Beck, with Beck he has no pressure, everyone knows there are no good QB's in free agency this year, everyone knows how bad our defence is likely to be, nobody thinks with beck that we will make a sudden turnaround and nobody will be too upset when we win less games this year than last, BECAUSE WE NOW EXPECT IT. If he starts Grossman, Rexy will have a few games that make you wonder why he isnt a HOF QB, and we will wonder why he doesnt have a better cast around him , because if he did, we should be a solid team, suddenly people will ask " its almost year 3, why arent we far better than this we look good in flashes" whereas Beck will maybe flash once in a while and we will say " man, what could this team do with a good QB I cant wait until we draft one and we see what he can do with this team in this system." If by some miracle he played even decently Shannahan recovers some of his lost shine because he scooped a decent QB off the scrap pile. even now some of the dumber fans are saying " its not shannys fault the defence sucks its all on haslett" this season when we are losing and losing big, we will be doing it while hoping that there is light at the end of the tunnel, and I will be saying " bravo Shannahan, well played"


