Great episode, gentlemen! Also great to hear the input of the legend, Kel Varnsen!
I really liked the Chase Young conversation. Would I trade him?
I think there are a couple things you need to take into consideration:
a) Resources - while it has been great all this time being able to trot out four first rounders on the D-line, we all know that sooner or later guys are going to want to get paid. We have had the luxury for the most part (minus Allen) of paying these guys based on their rookie contracts to this point. The day is soon coming where they are all going to want to get paid as we all know. I think we all knew in the back of our minds that when push comes to shove, the reality is that we would likely be able to keep two of them long-term. If we are really lucky, maybe a third can stick around if we get creative with the salary cap, while simultaneously not ignoring other areas of need on the team down the road.
b) Is Montez Sweat the real deal? If the answer to that question is yes, and you believe that he can consistently be a game wrecker, you might have to think long and hard about moving Young, especially if he can net you a large haul. I read something earlier this week indicating that the Panthers were turning down two first rounder for Brian Burns. If Young brings you something very comparable in return and you really like what Sweat brings to the table, maybe you role with Montez and don't look back.
c) Confidence in the FO's ability to draft - the best teams in the league are able to bring in productive, cheap labour via the draft. How do we feel about the job Rivera and his staff have done in terms of replacing talent via the draft? There have been some definite hits, but questions marks as well. In many regards, it has been a mixed bag. It's one thing to get a bunch of picks back in return for a talent like Young, it's a completely different animal to be able to put those picks to good use. Am I confident Rivera and his staff can make good on draft capital in exchange for Young? The jury is still out on that one...
All in all, it is a very hard question to answer with no definitive and obvious answer. That said, if you are convinced that Montez Sweat can prove himself to be a top five rusher in the NFL by season's end, I would certainly be listening to offers.