I’m definitely one of those posters who has concerns about Caleb Downs. It has been widely reported that an anonymous NFL scout at the combine said he had a partially torn meniscus and degenerative ACL injury, but you’re right that McAfee, Downs himself, and others have disputed that report. So call that a rumor or unconfirmed.
But then why is he avoiding running drills for scouts? As you noted, he skipped running at the combine, said he would do it at his pro day, then skipped that too. So what’s he hiding if not an injury? Maybe he knows his draft stock will sink if we learn how slow he is? It’s hard to see his refusal to work out for scouts as anything other than a red flag.
I hope you’re right that these concerns are overblown, because there’s a good chance we end up with Downs, and we haven’t had a truly great safety since Sean Taylor and Ryan Clark. When the season ended, I figured we would end up with Love or Downs based on their positions being undervalued, and I was happy about the idea of having either one of them at the time, so maybe it’s fine and I’m overreacting to the rumor mill, or maybe that’s wishful thinking. Time will tell.