philibusters props for all the work you are putting in
The PFF NFL stock exchange guys did their most recent mock, with trades, and had us trade down to 21 with Pittsburgh, in exchange for their 2nd, 3rd, and 4th.
I think it would be hard for me to make that trade unless we loaded some really premium free agents. We need impact players. I’d be inclined to stick and pick.
Also, as much as Kdawg has been selling me on Bain, those same PFF guys LOVE him. They think he is a clear both above Bailey, dismiss the concerns about arm length, and see him as a complete edge and an impact player.
Or TJ Watt who will turn 32 in October...Pitt is a good trade partner. They can sub in Highsmith or Herbig for one of those picks. They’d probably prefer to trade Highsmith given Herbig is emerging on the cheap.
I love Jayden. And I admit part of it is ego arguing with football friends of other teams but i don't think Jayden is considered the better of the 2024 class anymore with the national media or average fans. For this moment in time. And I put that blame on putting so much on Jayden's shoulders. Granted it doesn't matter. But at a minimum the idea that lets just put it on Jayden's shoulders and watch him shine and he doesn't need weapons like other QBs -- is a question.
Now, it is an open debate and it will change over time. But lol it bothers me that Jayden is now considered a question mark within some of the national media and casual fans.
And part of that narrative is IMO there are limits to how many scrubs you can give Jayden at WR. He got by in 2024 with a healthy Terry at the top of his game. Ekeler mostly healthy as a pass catching RB. Ditto Ertz. And Noah at least played in some games, Dyami, Zaccheus. It was a decent combination.
And you combine that with the easiest schedule in the NFL they made magic albiet a lot of close calls against medicore teams.
So now we got an aging and possibly injury prone Terry. No Ertz. No Ekeler. They need to rebuild their weapons.
We can laugh off Caleb getting every toy he wants under the Christmas tree -- give him three #1 type WRs talent wise, two good young TE's, better depth -- and we still got our Jayden so who cares. But there are some now who think Caleb > Jayden. And IMO that's mostly because of how loaded that Bears offense is so Caleb in turn has it much easier.
When Kurt Warner did his expose about how Jayden regressed this season by making the point that he's holding the ball too long and developing bad habits. Sheehan-Keim basically heard back from the team about yeah but......receivers aren't open and or running the wrong routes so he has his reasons for regression.
I am just not interested in going into a deeper dive to see if Jayden can make lemonade out of lemons. Let's give him a chance like the other young QBs have.
An older 31 year old Terry. Without Ertz. Probably without Deebo. Adds up to a weaker supporting class than the pathetic 2025 version. It's almost as code red to address this as is edge.
I get the point that you are trying to make, but I have to add that I won't be losing any sleep over what Ol' Butterface has to say
I watched Arvell Reese against Illinois and he was fantastic. He is incredibly violent. During the game Cory said that Reese and Leo Chenal from the 2022 class are the most violent linebackers he has scouted, and after watching this tape, that doesn’t feel like hyperbole.
Pass Rush: As a pass rusher, Reese is fairly reliant on the long arm — speed to power is clearly his foundation. I saw him use it against Illinois LT JC Davis (who is probably a Day 3 pick), RT Melvin Priestley, and TE Tanner Arkin. He drove Arkin back and pushed the pocket multiple times. He never really walked Davis straight back, but he did put Priestley on roller skates on one rep, which is impressive for a 245-pound linebacker. That said, he needs a runway. There was a rep where he crossed the guard’s face and then tried to convert to power on the center, but because most of his momentum was lateral, he didn’t have enough buildup and got stonewalled. From a wide 7 or 9 technique, the speed-to-power works well. From a tighter 5 technique alignment, there may not be enough runway for him to build speed and convert effectively. That is a bit different than a guy like Jared Verses who is maybe 15 pounds heavier and can convert speed to power from any technique. He also had a rep against RB Feagin (a big 230-pound back) where he got a full head of steam and went through him easily. He recorded a sack that was schemed up — he came free unblocked — so that one was more design than individual win. The other notable aspect of his pass rush is his lateral quickness. He can win inside across the blocker’s face, and that quickness is very real. However, his pass rush plan is still raw. It’s mostly long arm/speed to power and inside counters. Despite reportedly running sub-4.5 (around 4.48), I didn’t see him attempt pure speed rushes to flatten and turn the corner. He prefers contact and seems naturally inclined toward converting through power rather than winning with bend.
Run Defense: This phase looked elite. I saw him play as both a stacked linebacker and as an edge setter on the line of scrimmage. As a stack backer, he was disciplined and instinctive. He scraped cleanly in the box, maneuvered well through traffic, and showed excellent sideline-to-sideline range. He had three sideline tackles — two on run plays and one in the flat in coverage — and the range really pops. When taking on pulling guards, he punches with violence. I counted roughly three reps against pullers. On at least one, he stacked and shed cleanly. On another, he delivered a strong punch and held his ground even though he didn’t disengage — Caleb Downs came downhill and cleaned it up. The key is he was not displaced. As an edge setter, he was outstanding. I saw him set the edge 7–8 times — several against tackles and a couple against TEs — and he never lost it. He can stack, peek, and shed. There was one rep against JC Davis where he set the edge properly but missed the tackle on QB Luke Altmyer after disengaging. Sonny Styles cleaned it up for no gain. Even when he doesn’t finish, the structural work is correct.
Coverage: He was solid here too. He gave up two receptions. One came on a spot route when he was in hook zone and the receiver wrapped around him. The other was tight coverage on a tight end — no real separation, good leverage by the offense, and the ball was on the money. Reese was punching at the catch point. He had 3–4 good man reps against tight ends and running backs. He looked fluid and fast. He’ll punch receivers if they cross his face — again, he naturally likes contact. In Cover 2 looks, he handled his assignments cleanly. In one Cover 3 rep as a hook defender, he showed good awareness by gaining depth to protect against a potential dig route. Nothing flashy in coverage, but strong, assignment-sound tape.
Overall: This was excellent film from Reese. I’ve heard he had less impressive games later in the season, but this one was high-level. He looked elite against the run and good in both coverage and as a pass rusher, with room to grow in the rush plan. If Washington were to run something in the Brian Flores mold — similar to what the Vikings do — Reese would be outstanding in an Andrew Van Ginkel-type role. You can:
He would need to expand the pass rush bag, but speed to power is a legitimate foundation for him. In my opinion, he would be an excellent pick at 7.
- Play him stacked and let him fit gaps
- Walk him up and let him set edges
- Drop him in man on TEs and RBs
- Use him as a speed-to-power rusher with space
Unfortunately, there isn’t a shorter YouTube cut of this film. Daft on Draft didn’t start making condensed versions for YouTube until November, and this game was from October. That’s the case with several players Washington has been linked to at 7 — Kendrick Faulk and Mekai Lemon included — which means no corresponding video for them.
One thing about Bain that gives me pause for the Commanders drafting him at 7, it's AP and what he says he likes in a DE/Edge. He likes taller, long armed players and is why the only ones I can recall him making serious attempts or looks at were Hendrickson, Bosa and Garrett. They are around 6' 4"-6'5" and about 265-270 which has been AP's profile. I know, we are possibly going to be in more of 3-4 or other alignments but something to think about
Sticking with AP. The other position that I recall having more in depth conversation about is TE. TE and DE were the two positions he played and has special place in his heart so he tries emphasizing their importance. His favorite all time players are TE's. I see him swinging at a good TE. That said, I am not sure that player is in the draft. There are some intriguing ones that could be there within the 3rd round or later but not a sure thing or does he look to trade down and take Sadiq, seeing him as a potential game changer? I hope that isn't the plan but just thought I'd throw that out. I think he goes after a big name TE in FA.
I wish Bain had 32 inch arms, I can deal with that. But supposedly just over 30. And also supposedly small hands, too.
If Bain was at 32 no one would be saying he'd be the first ever with arms like that to be a stud in the NFL. Parsons at 31.5 is a speed rusher, I could see a speed rusher overcoming it. Plus Parsons has massive hands.
Not saying Bain isn't going to be successful. And its cool that PFf in particular doesn't give a rats behind about it and think he will be the first outlier big success in the NFL with those arms. I just don't know myself. I am not negative or positive on Bain -- am agnostic.
I did not realize Hendricksons arms were only 32 inches. Bains official arm measurements will be one the most watched numbers prior to the draft.Myles Garret has 35 inch arms and Bosa is just under 34 inches. However, Trey Hendrickson is one the guys along with Micah Parson, Hassan Reddick, and Aidan Hutchison who I always cite as being good pass rushers despite having short arms. Hendrickson was at 32 inches even, Parsons at 31.5 inches, Reddick 32.5 inches, and Hutchison 32 and 1/8th.
I'll get to Reese in more depth. I watched the Indiana game and he was IMO meh in that one but Styles was unbelievable.

I wish Bain had 32 inch arms, I can deal with that. But supposedly just over 30. And also supposedly small hands, too.
If Bain was at 32 no one would be saying he'd be the first ever with arms like that to be a stud in the NFL. Parsons at 31.5 is a speed rusher, I could see a speed rusher overcoming it. Plus Parsons has massive hands.
Not saying Bain isn't going to be successful. And its cool that PFf in particular doesn't give a rats behind about it and think he will be the first outlier big success in the NFL with those arms. I just don't know myself. I am not negative or positive on Bain -- am agnostic.
I did not realize Hendricksons arms were only 32 inches. Bains official arm measurements will be one the most watched numbers prior to the draft.
Great write ups on the players. I did not realize Reese was that violent, loved reading that. He has had a great career and has lots of good games. I do have concern over how it appeared to me he semi disappeared during his final games. At the same time that occurred Styles stole his spotlight and I'm sure a part of the reason he is sliding up boards.

I agree with SkinsinParadise that Bain is a power rusher, but “power rusher” can mean different things depending on how narrowly you define it. When most people hear power rush, they immediately think bull rush — a straight-line drive through the chest of the tackle. That’s not really Bain’s game, and given his shorter arms, it probably never will be. He’s not built to consistently win by locking out and walking tackles straight back. But at 272 pounds with roughly 90th percentile get-off (compared to around 44th percentile top speed), he’s elite at converting acceleration into power through the O-Lineman's outside shoulder. His explosiveness off the ball is what allows him to generate force early in the rep. His go-to move is a club-rip, which can absolutely be classified as a speed-to-power move because it relies on violent force and displacement rather than pure edge bend. Because he’s 6'2", compact, explosive, and has tremendous core strength, you’ll see him execute forklift-style rushes. He may not always literally lift linemen off the ground, but he raises their center of gravity, gets them off balance, and then works around them. That’s functional power. He wins through leverage, lower-body explosion, and torque. So if you define “power rusher” narrowly as a long-armed bull rusher who drives straight through the chest plate, then no — Bain isn’t that and likely never will be. But if you use a broader definition that includes speed-to-power, leverage-based displacement, and strength-driven rush moves, then he absolutely qualifies as a power rusher.
I do agree with you point that he is is a good hand fighter and can use lateral quickness on inside counters. But I feel that is all set up from a foundation of speed to power. The O-Lineman has to respect the speed to power and other stuff he does takes advantage of the O-Lineman's respect for that speed to power.