- Joined
- Jul 15, 2009
- Messages
- 15,892
- Reaction score
- 9,226
- Points
- 1,093
- Location
- W Palm Beach & Helsinki
One thing I’ve always had reservations about with the Kliff hire (since when you have a defensive HC all you worry about if you’re successful is “how long until someone takes our QB’s playcaller? One of the things I hate about it) is that his offense doesn’t really have a coaching tree. So you’re hiring a guy whose offense is fairly singular in this league, and tying your young QB to it. I hated that.
My huge hope is that we haven’t spent the past two years thinking Kliff was grooming Brian Johnson or Lynn for the job as they’ve been immersed in his system. That was one reason I was happy to see Pritchard hired away elsewhere, to hopefully avoid that temptation. Blough has a promising rep but very little experience, it’s too soon. I don’t want them handing this offense to a Kliff understudy if it doesn’t work with him, I want change.
Consistency and continuity for a young QB can be paramount, yes. But not when you’re continuing bad things (that few around the league are experts in, given Kliff’s semi-unique coaching journey to the NFL). I’d rather Daniels start over now in a system that has more of a foundation of working across this league (for instance—but not necessarily—a Shanahan variant) than play another 1-2 years under Kliff and have to do it later, when we’re trying to re-sign him to a monster contract extension. That’s why I didn’t like the hire. So just do it now, if it feels right.
But trying to hand the reigns to someone who will keep the same scheme and terminology for Daniels for continuity, but likely adhere more closely to the sort of game plans Quinn and AP want…that would be the quickest way for me to give up on this current regime. Hand these playcalling reigns to Brian Johnson or Anthony Lynn in the same system and I’m out on the whole thing until it inevitably crashes and burns. They need to hire from the outside and bring in a new scheme before spending all that FA money and drafting rookies. If they’re gonna make a move now is the time.
It won’t be devastating for Daniels, he’s a smart kid and looked better in year 1 in the league when he was a newbie. Look at Trevor Lawrence this year. Took about half the season but he’s rejuvenated in that Coen offense and he was really teetering on bust territory. Caleb & Ben Johnson, same thing. Goff was more of a vet but adjusted quickly to Ben Johnson after being traded to the Rams. Mike McDaniel salvaged multiple productive years out of the Tua potato before that fell apart. Young is limited but Canales was able to improve him and is well on his way to maximizing that twerp.
I think healthy and confident Jayden Daniels maximized and bailed out Kliff, not the other way around. He’ll be alright, and we’ll be helping him out by getting him in a better scheme with more of a succession plan if he gets his playcallers hired away.
I hope that rumor’s true, is what I’m saying. And I hope they don’t try to sell us an in-house option. I have respect for our assistants, at the level they’re currently at. I don’t want microwaved Kliff leftovers when I didn’t like fresh-out-the-oven Kliff.
Nice post. Beat me to a couple of my first thoughts.One thing I’ve always had reservations about with the Kliff hire (since when you have a defensive HC all you worry about if you’re successful is “how long until someone takes our QB’s playcaller? One of the things I hate about it) is that his offense doesn’t really have a coaching tree. So you’re hiring a guy whose offense is fairly singular in this league, and tying your young QB to it. I hated that.
My huge hope is that we haven’t spent the past two years thinking Kliff was grooming Brian Johnson or Lynn for the job as they’ve been immersed in his system. That was one reason I was happy to see Pritchard hired away elsewhere, to hopefully avoid that temptation. Blough has a promising rep but very little experience, it’s too soon. I don’t want them handing this offense to a Kliff understudy if it doesn’t work with him, I want change.
Consistency and continuity for a young QB can be paramount, yes. But not when you’re continuing bad things (that few around the league are experts in, given Kliff’s semi-unique coaching journey to the NFL). I’d rather Daniels start over now in a system that has more of a foundation of working across this league (for instance—but not necessarily—a Shanahan variant) than play another 1-2 years under Kliff and have to do it later, when we’re trying to re-sign him to a monster contract extension. That’s why I didn’t like the hire. So just do it now, if it feels right.
But trying to hand the reigns to someone who will keep the same scheme and terminology for Daniels for continuity, but likely adhere more closely to the sort of game plans Quinn and AP want…that would be the quickest way for me to give up on this current regime. Hand these playcalling reigns to Brian Johnson or Anthony Lynn in the same system and I’m out on the whole thing until it inevitably crashes and burns. They need to hire from the outside and bring in a new scheme before spending all that FA money and drafting rookies. If they’re gonna make a move now is the time.
It won’t be devastating for Daniels, he’s a smart kid and looked better in year 1 in the league when he was a newbie. Look at Trevor Lawrence this year. Took about half the season but he’s rejuvenated in that Coen offense and he was really teetering on bust territory. Caleb & Ben Johnson, same thing. Goff was more of a vet but adjusted quickly to Ben Johnson after being traded to the Rams. Mike McDaniel salvaged multiple productive years out of the Tua potato before that fell apart. Young is limited but Canales was able to improve him and is well on his way to maximizing that twerp.
I think healthy and confident Jayden Daniels maximized and bailed out Kliff, not the other way around. He’ll be alright, and we’ll be helping him out by getting him in a better scheme with more of a succession plan if he gets his playcallers hired away.
I hope that rumor’s true, is what I’m saying. And I hope they don’t try to sell us an in-house option. I have respect for our assistants, at the level they’re currently at. I don’t want microwaved Kliff leftovers when I didn’t like fresh-out-the-oven Kliff.
Agreed. Same for a new OC hire. New blood at both DC and OC.I pray the DC is not a hire from within. I want new blood.
Nice post. Beat me to a couple of my first thoughts.
I do worry they will advance OC from within and there will not be enough change for what we could really use. It feels like a DQ move to move Johnson or Lynn up. One of them may have even been promised the position when hired if KK left after a year, who knows on that front.
I pray the DC is not a hire from within. I want new blood.
One question and I can see you all going either way with this one - is AP overstepping his head coach in making this call or in having disconnect? I get his position and that he may not agree with some of Kliffs beliefs or moves, I know I didn't.
And it's completely stunted Hurts.No. Howie does that all the time in Philly.
And it's completely stunted Hurts.
Fangio won them a super bowl, along with Barkley having a historic year. Hurts has gotten worse every year.It won them a Super Bowl last year
Nice post. Beat me to a couple of my first thoughts.
I do worry they will advance OC from within and there will not be enough change for what we could really use. It feels like a DQ move to move Johnson or Lynn up. One of them may have even been promised the position when hired if KK left after a year, who knows on that front.
I pray the DC is not a hire from within. I want new blood.
One question and I can see you all going either way with this one - is AP overstepping his head coach in making this call or in having disconnect? I get his position and that he may not agree with some of Kliffs beliefs or moves, I know I didn't.
Fangio won them a super bowl, along with Barkley having a historic year. Hurts has gotten worse every year.
There's risk to the status quo, as there is with overhauling the staff. Given Daniels and Kingsbury's relationship, it would be very risky to just unceremoniously dump him.
This resonates with me. His propensity to put JD in harms way along with JD going super hero too much makes me very afraid he stays healthy enough to have a long career.He doesn’t seem to be learning that Daniels does not have good vision or decision-making on RPO’s, and that he’s much better as a scrambler when things break down. Still keeps slamming him into the defensive front-7 a bunch of times per game, even when he’s hurting and our entire franchise depends on his health and productivity. Doesn’t protect him by leaning on the running game, even when it’s working.