And even though we have seen glimpses of competence since Quinn took over play calling... Are there really many players on defense we'd regret losing?
Regret? I dont know that you'd kick yourself.
The bigger question is are there any guys on this defense you think you can win with... and I say absolutely. The unfortunate thing is it's going to take a couple BIG hits at premium positions, but the Defense likely can get turned around quick.
1. Premium Edge pushes everyone else down the Depth Chart, benefiting all of them.
2. Healthy CB + scheme change. I actually don't think CB is the biggest 'need' as far as personnel... Of course this is predicated on Amos and what he can be come, but if you're talking talent within a unit, this one, on paper, is imho capable, and it's also been as heavily invested in as any unit when you talk about drafting players (Amos / Sainristil), trading for players (Lattimore), and signing players (Noah I, Jonathan Jones). I think the system has been more detrimental to the unit than the players have been.
3. Interior D-Line. Kinlaw seems to have moments, but i still think there's something missing (clearly). We HAVE to figure out the run defense. Doing that has the type of ripple effect that changes all aspects of the defense, front to back. Allowing teams to absolutely gash us pushes the problems out like a shockwave. I put Interior D-line here, but i also wonder if there is a schematic button we can push. Not sure what personnel outside of having multiple All Pro DT come in here that can just disrupt the entire interior line... and that's not exactly a realistic expectation. I love the idea of Darryl Tapp, but wonder if an upgrade can happen at that position, whether it be Tapp changing him process / philosophy, or you move on to another D-Line coach. Again, this is not saying it's all on the D-line, I just wonder if thats the place you can make the most impact with the least amount of changes.