CuredFromBatteredFanSyndrome
The 1st Round Pick
We all have our gripes about the state of the roster and the schedule is a murderers row, but I feel very about JD bouncing back. I’d bet on it, but I want it to actually happen.
We all have our gripes about the state of the roster and the schedule is a murderers row, but I feel very about JD bouncing back. I’d bet on it, but I want it to actually happen.
Just bear in mind, some average QBs were made to look good not by their supporting cast on O but the quality of their D. In fact, some do argue that the D plays a much bigger role in the success and failure of O than people realize (less pressure to score every time and with complementary football, you end up applying pressure on the opponents).Jayden is a stud. And the fact that its not escaping most national observors that he has one of the weakest supporting casts in the NFL should help the legend when he has a big season in spite of it.
I think the lack of help makes him fall short of a SB run. But he's one of those special QBs, that can make lemonade out of lemons. Maybe an unintended consequence of making him shoulder the load every season like he's already Mahomes in his prime, that when he finally gets a regular slate of weapons (doesn't even have to be great, just average), he will take off even more.
Just bear in mind, some average QBs were made to look good not by their supporting cast on O but the quality of their D. In fact, some do argue that the D plays a much bigger role in the success and failure of O than people realize (less pressure to score every time and with complementary football, you end up applying pressure on the opponents).
I heard JP say that he “heard” one of the thoughts was to strengthen the D and help loosen Jayden up that way; he can relax more and not feel like he has to score on every drive.
I get that we should be able to do more, especially at WR (I read your points). Just saying that it will be interesting to see how far they go with this strategy. I am not sure their strategy is so awful, especially with a new OC. Let’s see how they look in real games. But yes in Y3 you’d like to be in a different spot but the reality is, before the season even begins, we know we have a lot to learn with TWO new coordinators.
I think your last point is what is the most disturbing. When you look at the WR corps you have a lot riding on this rookie to be good or very good at least, and then thw group looks “ok” - otherwise it is likely below average. Not good from that viewpoint.



Yes, great post. I actually think we'd be griping about spending $31mil/yr for Alec Pearce and would not have had the ammo to go after other pieces that we needed, especially on defense. Mr. 1.5 catches per game guy is worth nowhere near the amount of money he got. It's crazy how much he made based on potential alone.The other thing to keep in mind is that money doesn't solve everything. Just because we have a ton of cap space doesn't mean there is an equal amount of free agency quality. That' not to say that adding Pierce, Doubs, or even Diggs wouldn't have given us more peace of mind because it would have, but none of those three signings would have been long term heroes to set our corp for several years going forward. Paying A+ money for a B player gets you in trouble. Frankly, Pierce and Doubs were both only good players. Better than what we have, but neither look to be stars in the making.
One of the things that is obviously true in the NFL, and which fans give verbal acknowledgement to, is that you can't rebuild an entire roster in a season or two. It takes time. GMs will try to do exactly that, but there will be players they pursue but can't sign. There will be picks they make that don't pan out. There will be injuries and other surprises.
While we as fans all know this from an intellectual standpoint, our expectations are that Adam Peters does exactly that. We pretty much expect and demand it every offseasonWe are fans and what we do best is say things that are reasonable and defensible and rational. But our fan selves also hate losing. We have not seeing dramatic improvements. We hate missing the playoffs. And we react emotionally to all of that when the stars don't line up for our guys (like they did in 2024).
I think Blough and Quinn and Peters fully recognize our WR corps isn't where it needs to be. They swung and missed on the top free agent WRs. Maybe they planned on taking Carnell Tate had he been there at 7, who knows? But the bottom line is, while we improved our talent in multiple areas this offseason (good for AP), our talent at WR is arguably worse than it was in 2025. So Peters still has work to do. Whether they are able to pull something out of their rear ends with Aiyuk or Diggs remains to be seen. But I think it's quite possible our situation at WR is what we have to live with in 2026 and that doesn't necessarily 'reflect' on the Front Office - but to my original point is part of how difficult it is to fill every need in an offseason or two.


The other thing to keep in mind is that money doesn't solve everything. Just because we have a ton of cap space doesn't mean there is an equal amount of free agency quality. That' not to say that adding Pierce, Doubs, or even Diggs wouldn't have given us more peace of mind because it would have, but none of those three signings would have been long term heroes to set our corp for several years going forward. Paying A+ money for a B player gets you in trouble. Frankly, Pierce and Doubs were both only good players. Better than what we have, but neither look to be stars in the making.
But I think that potential is the key difference. We can envision him and a bunch of the other defensive free agents being able to ascend to a higher level. Do we think the offensive guys we've mentioned our ready to take a leap and become a star?We can say the same thing though to discount the defensive additions. The defense sucked. Just throwing money at it this off season should be taken with a grain of salt because as far as we know the defense might just as likely suck next season as it did the same before.
Some nationall said actually what you did about Pierce as to the Oweh signing -- an overpayment for a dude based on potential not production. If we are trusting that Peters nailed it with these type of signings on the defense it would be contradictory to trust his judgment on going after Pierce and feeling lucky that he didn't land that fish IMO.


I think you (and others - myself included) who argue that the Front Office deviated somewhat from a full-on rebuild plan after the surprising success in 2024 are correct. That slowed our progress. And then moving on from both coordinators (whether justified or not) is also going to slow our progress and perhaps even result in previous acquisitions not being the greatest fits for the schemes our new coordinators are implementing. All of that is not an indictment of AP or anyone else, just part of the learning curve for a new GM.