Recent content by Voice_of_Reason

  1. Voice_of_Reason

    The Jayden Daniels Tracker

    Right. We were playing with a rookie QB making his first start, new HC, new everything, and we played a team that ended up winning their division. Who we then beat in the playoffs. But Tampa was a good team, especially early in the season. My point is losing to Tampa in that spot and...
  2. Voice_of_Reason

    The All Things Offensive Line Thread

    Eh. He played "fine" last year. I'm going to say "fine" is serviceable. You're not going to have an all-pro at every position, and he was signed to be a backup. He's playing because Tunsil got hurt. I can live with that level player as a backup. I'd be much more concerned if the plan was...
  3. Voice_of_Reason

    The Front Office: Adam Peters and Roster Construction

    Eh. I mean, do you give Polin credit for drafting Peyton Manning? It was the consensus pick, but he pulled the trigger. I don't think there are such things as luxury picks. You pick the guy who is highest on your board. Newton was a bad pick. I think it's as simple as that. Injury and...
  4. Voice_of_Reason

    Official Game Thread - Preseason Week 2 - Commander @ Lions

    1. I don't think THEY would say Biadasz was a solid center. You are. They never said they thought he was solid. 2. Where we agree, (I think) is after they released Biadasz, they had to do more than extending Allegretti, drafting a guy in the 6th round, and relying on a practice squad player...
  5. Voice_of_Reason

    Official Game Thread - Preseason Week 2 - Commander @ Lions

    Ah, I guess I got that wrong. My apologies. I really thought 70 was average.
  6. Voice_of_Reason

    Official Game Thread - Preseason Week 2 - Commander @ Lions

    I think competition is one thing. Taking a 2 year starter here, and a starter for several years in Dallas, and then actively going out to find their replacement, I think that's different than having Chris Paul compete with Coleman, or something like that. Biadasz has to see himself as the...
  7. Voice_of_Reason

    Official Game Thread - Preseason Week 2 - Commander @ Lions

    One really important thing to remember: it's still preseason. They aren't game planning, they are working on specific things, and they are often putting players in position to be man on man with an opponent to see how they do. Don't draw grand conclusions from anything that happens in...
  8. Voice_of_Reason

    Official Game Thread - Preseason Week 2 - Commander @ Lions

    I'd add Tyler Owens made some play, and it was really good. I don't remember what the play was, but I do remember commenting on it. JD had 3 plays: 1. Shotgun, was looking for some type of a chunk play, got immediate pressure and threw the ball away. 2. Under-center play-action, got immediate...
  9. Voice_of_Reason

    Official Game Thread - Preseason Week 2 - Commander @ Lions

    That's actually not true. The plan for a tackle getting injured short term was Wylie and Trent Scott. Both of which are absolutely viable short term professional OL backups. And the plan for backup at guard was Paul, Wylie and Trent Scott. The plan for a long term injury to either Tunsil...
  10. Voice_of_Reason

    Washington Redskins Football Team Commanders History Discussion Thread

    I don't think he ever thought Beck was any good. I thought he might be as good as Grossman. He took the job, and that's step one. If he wasn't willing to learn, then he didn't have to take the job. Kliff could always go back to college. Or just sit out and kindof do nothing since Arizona...
  11. Voice_of_Reason

    Do the Commanders have trade bait?

    We're going to cut a WR this year who's either going to be claimed to another team's 53 or at the very least, will get elevated from a practice squad. Maybe 2. The depth of that room was never the question, the question was always the top of the room. It would be ideal to flip a WR for a...
  12. Voice_of_Reason

    The All Things Offensive Line Thread

    I think Coleman is going to be fine at LT. Somewhere up in this thread, there is a clip with Nick Aldridge and whatshisname British film bread down guy where they show a Coleman block which is just spectacular, very few LTs can make it. Paul will be serviceable at LG. They have to figure...
  13. Voice_of_Reason

    Official Game Thread - Preseason Week 2 - Commander @ Lions

    You're missing what effect keeping a player on your roster and then trying to replace them does to their psyche. And everybody knew we were attempting to upgrade center. Linderbaum was plan A, Keim said there was a plan B. Biadasz would have known that. When both plans failed, then you turn...
  14. Voice_of_Reason

    The Jayden Daniels Tracker

    You never look at the rush. If you do, you're late on every throw. This year's camp has been extremely competitive. All reports are this is probably one of the hardest camps in a decade.
  15. Voice_of_Reason

    The Jayden Daniels Tracker

    I don't think we had a slow start in 2024. We played a playoff team in week one with a rookie QB making his first NFL start and lost. We then won 4 in a row and 7 of 8. That's not a slow start.
See more
Help Users

You haven't joined any rooms.

    You haven't joined any rooms.
    Top