Not going to disagree with any of it, my confidence level if our WR group is this come week 1 is not exactly beaming in that unit. That said I don't think it needs to be. If we had THIS defense in 2024... phew. If we had this defense in 2025 i think it's a dynamically different conversation. There clearly is an argument that we would have preferred to do things surrounding Jayden a bit faster, but we're here now. 1st full offseason we overhauled the O-line. Now we have what appears to be a pretty stable unit for at least 2 more years. Now his 2nd full offseason, the defensive front 7, and it now looks like we have it locked up for more than just one rental season. I've said before and i'll continue to say... we can't fix it all in a single offseason, so I am doing a little convincing myself that he's doing things in phases based on whats available..... we'll see if it continues
He's killed it everywhere but WR and RB, so got no complaints YET. But at least at WR, he tried.
I do think his first two years were underwhelming for Jayden and looks borderline pathetic when you compare it to the urgency of the Bears to do whatever they can to help Caleb shine and to some degree the other teams who took QBs in the 2024 draft. This year is underwhelming, too on that front so far but not as bad as 2024 but close -- but I don't think he's finished. As I like to say you can walk and chew gum at the same time, Patriots rebuilt their defense last year, Denver built a killer defense, Falcons rapidly improved their pass rush while also having great weapons for Penix. Bears not as much on defense but at least they create turnovers.
So it took Peters 3 years to arguaby finally put good talent together on defense. That's not hot. But if I am judging him purely based on this off season, awesome job. Took 2 seasons to build an O line -- that's good. 3 seasons thus far to still not build a support cast for your young QB -- that's bad. Yes, you can't do it all in one off season but he's had three off seasons to do it. And had plenty of draft picks to draft or for trade capital and plenty of cap space.
Drafting Wrs in the late third, and late 4th, and taking a RB in the 7th round, with WRs off the street littering the team shows that weapons for Jayden isn't a high priority for Peters compared to other spots. And yeah I'd forgive it if he killed it with the other spots, but he didn't do so save the O line.
And loved the ride in 2024 but also the hype that bled into the 2025 off season. And Peters IMO helped sqaunder that with how little he did for Jayden and it was glaring when you compare it to the Bears among other teams. As I said before when you got Kurt Warner running a video about how Jayden regressed and then days later you got Sheehan and Keim hearing from the team that the video is wrong because yeah Jayden may look to have regressed but those poor habits are just a function of the WRs not being up to snuff. That's nauseating to me. To see some analyists I like say Jayden is the third best QB now from that class. To see another say Doubs chose the Pats over Washington because Maye >> Jayden. To hear a Giants reporter say their team has a franchise QB but doesn't think Washington does. What a come down both in performance and perception about Jayden and this team and Peters has his fingerprints all over it.
If this current configuration of the WR and RB corp is who they go to battle with, I give Peters a C for this off season. Yes he finally addressed the defense the right way or so it seems it took him 3 years that's a long time. the Pats rebuilt their defense in 2 years. Denver saddled with bad cap issues and lack of draft picks built their defense fast. So cool that he did finally get to it but its about time.
Having said that I don't think Peters is done at WR and RB. So for now its an incomplete grade. But I don't think Peters is dumb so i don't think he's going to double down on giving Jayden a meh to worse supporting cast three years in a row. He at least showed that he's williing to swing at the WR position this off season. And while I think the current WR-RB group is arguably in his current configuration even worse than 2025. I doubt he's resting on this where its job done.
Right now I'd say the 2026 RBs is a weaker group than what they started with in 2025. The starting WRs 2026 currently a weaker crop than 2025 -- but depth way better. But I don't think the season will start with McCaffrey as the startiing slot. And Van Jefferson as the starting Z. I think more is to come.
But that's my long winded way of saying love what Peters has done this off season. I think three years is plenty of time to rebuild the roster. So whatever he doesn't rebuild its on him. So while I agree tough to rebuild a crap roster overnight -- its his crap roster, his mistakes he's fixing. After three years, I can't blame the previous regime. And if he rebuilds the supporting cast, he will get me back in a big way. I am not as negative on Peters as some. I think he's shown some savvy in his endeavors among his mistakes and some of his mistakes are understandable but I am as negative as anyone when it comes to the topic of helping Jayden with a running game/WRs.
Peters has done a very nice job fixing his mistakes on defense this off season. Three off seasons in I am not blaming Ron anymore. And I like a lot what he's done on the O line. But when these other teams with young QBs to use a cooking metaphor will import the best ingredients they can find to make it hard for their chefs to screw up the meal and work to build their confidence on that front by giving them high end products that make it almost impossible to screw up the meal. Peters took the opposite approach, our young chef is so good we will prove it by giving him some powdered mash potatoes and ramen noodles and he wll crank out a gourmet meal anyway just you watch! -- I hate that. I can let go of all of Peters mistakes but not that.
Does a defense help Jayden you bet. But its not like these other teams with young QBs haven't addressed that issue, too -- Peters is late to that party but at least he joined it now. Now finish the job and give Jayden some weapons for a change. I am not interested in seeing if Von Jefferson can revive his career as the starting Z. Or the time has come for us to trust McCaffrey as the slot. That's the rodeo Peters has been on for the last two years. It did work in 2024 but failed in 2025. This corp in its current configuration IMO is closer to the bad 2025 group then the mediocre 2024 one. But again I don't think he's finished so I'll judge it when he's finished. And considering he swung at Pierce and Doubs, he gets it. So I am feeling good that it will happen, will see.