• Welcome to BGO! We know you will have questions as you become familiar with the software. Please take a moment to read our New BGO User Guide which will give you a great start. If you have questions, post them in the Feedback and Tech Support Forum, or feel free to message any available Staff Member.

The NFL Lawsuit That Could Be Bigger Than the Bounty Scandal

Lanky Livingston


The NFL Lawsuit That Could Be Bigger Than The Bounty Scandal
Barry Petchesky

From: Barry Petchesky
To: John Koblin, Nate Jackson

The overturning of four Saints' bounty suspensions was a massive victory not just for the the weakest union in pro sports, but for the collective bargaining process in itself. The appeals panel didn't find that the players were innocent—it didn't even consider the question—but rather that commissioner Roger Goodell had stepped outside his jurisdiction when he unilaterally handed down punishments and then upheld his own ruling. The CBA did exactly what it was supposed to do: It dictated the actions that management was allowed take against labor, and it offered the redress of an independent appeals process.

Bountygate may end up being a sideshow, though—a Wavre to Reggie White et al. v. NFL's Waterloo. Preliminary arguments began Thursday in Minneapolis in a lawsuit against the league that harks back to the worst sports scandals of the last generation: unrestrained collusion among the owners to keep payrolls down. (And let's remember: Every major issue baseball faced in the '90s—the strike, the steroids, the unrestrained expansion—has its roots in the collusion of the previous decade.)

The NFL has an incredible recent record of seeing its disputes end up in court. The Saints players brought a lawsuit, still pending, over the bounty suspensions. Last year, after temporarily decertifying the union, the players filed an antitrust suit seeking to prevent a lockout. We can add to that the Supreme Court smacking down the league's merchandising monopoly and the never-ending concussion lawsuits and now White v. NFL. Has there ever been an established league that spent more time in courtrooms defending its very foundations than Roger Goodell's NFL?

The facts in the White case are straightforward and damning, and largely agreed upon by both sides. In 2010, the last year of an expiring labor deal, there was no salary cap. Teams were ostensibly free to carry whatever payroll they could afford, but in their summer meetings the owners came to a secret agreement. No one would cross the $123 million boundary, because if some teams spent freely, that would drive up prices for teams that would rather not spend at all.

The imaginary salary cap "came up several times in our meetings," said John Mara, Giants owner and chairman of the NFL's management committee. Still, four teams took the gentlemen's agreement as something less than binding, because after all: There was no actual rule. The Redskins, Cowboys, Raiders, and Saints all spent more than $123 million, despite being warned "at least six times" that serious consequences would follow. And sure enough, the gavel came down. This season and next, Washington and Dallas (the two biggest spenders) will forfeit a combined $46 million in salary cap space, to be distributed among the other teams.

In other words: Dan Snyder and Jerry Jones are being punished for failing to collude with their fellow owners in a secret deal to keep hundreds of millions of dollars out of the hands of NFL players.

The NFL's initial justification, when it announced the penalties this spring, was laughable. A league statement cited "an unacceptable risk to future competitive balance," as if this were a matter of the sport's integrity rather than a transparent cash grab. Officials dropped that line of defense when it was pointed out that seven teams spent less than the previous year's salary floor without being punished. The next tack: a nonsensical appeal to justice, in which the only jurors were the same owners who had agreed to the imaginary salary cap in the first place. Sure enough, a unanimous vote upheld the Redskins' and Cowboys' punishments.

Click link for the rest.


The Legend
BGO Ownership Group
Feb 1, 2010
Reaction score
Waynesboro, VA

James Madison

Thanks for posting, Lanky. Talk about raising some interesting issues, wow. The NFL really stepped out of line with the Cap-Gate penalties, it will be fascinating to watch if their tacit admission of collusion will get them in trouble somewhere.


reading now, but deadspin's relentless use of half of snyder's face in pictures is ****ing hilarious.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Total: 1, Members: 0, Guests: 1)

Private conversations
Help Users
As we enjoy today's conversations, let's remember our dear friends 'Docsandy', Sandy Zier-Teitler, and 'Posse Lover', Michael Huffman, who would dearly love to be here with us today! We love and miss you guys ❤