Always Commander Never Captain
The UDFA
Not specifically about the players because you guys know so much more about them and it is great reading so thanks—
But one thing that has frustrated me all year is the nagging feeling that AP did not go BPA in the first this year. I thought it is basic draft science for the smart GMs which I also thought AP was.
I can’t get my head around it. Campbell was - I thought- consensus first rounder, and Josh was not, especially not early/mid. So BPA was clear. Eagles wanted that trade because the value dynamic was there. It made sense. So the double whammy was not trading down (when you knew or should have known this guy you wanted wasn’t consensus at that spot) or not getting BPA.
I guess Campbell had an injury, maybe that is why. So maybe AP has a heavier devalue on injuries but if so, can’t figure Newton since his was worse.
I like Connerly personality and think he has talent, but I feel like it is relatively proven that BPA builds winners more consistently. I can’t shake the feeling that either AP made a single mistake here or his philosophy is broken. I am pretty worried it could be the latter because of other moves (like the Dejean move).
Someone correct me here, but if I recall we had several trade offers. One was for Pearce if he fell, but Atlanta wound up trading up past us anyways. Another was Kansas City looking to take an OT (unclear if we knew which one they wanted), and then there was a team in the 2nd round that wanted to move up but they thought the drop would have been too far.
Does that sound familiar to anyone else?