 }})
- Joined
- Sep 28, 2010
- Messages
- 19,626
- Reaction score
- 125
- Points
- 343
- Location
- BGO's Official Resident "Tech Dummy"
This is baffling me.
Aldrick Robinson seems like the perfect player, or at least the most appropriate player on our roster, to return punts/kicks.
Some thoughts.....
1) no-one else has stepped up.
2) how about that speed ?
3) he's got the "hands" to receive kicks, obviously, since he's a receiver (nevermind yesterday's non-call TD)
4) he did it somewhat in college, and the coach wanted to use him more there, but the only reason he didn't do it more, was because he was a starting receiver....which brings me to #5.......
5) he's not a starting receiver here, so we don't have to worry about risking injury to a key player.
I'm sure there's more reasons, but that's plenty. But I can't think of any reason not to.
So, why havn't I heard his name mentioned ?
Shanahan instead puts in Morgan to return kicks, because he's got a "big body".
Big Body ? What's the logic there ? Are we trying to do the complete opposite of Brandon Banks miniature frame, since the midget Banks was a dismal failure ? Come on, "being big" does not qualify you for being a returner. I don't support Banks' diminutive size, but the opposite - being big can actually work against you, as a returner.
Being "big" also makes you a bigger target to grab a hold of and tackle. Straight-ahead speed is more important. And agility. And Morgan certainly doesn't have those as his strengths. Aldrick does. So why isn't he being considered ? Is he in the dog-house ?
Aldrick Robinson seems like the perfect player, or at least the most appropriate player on our roster, to return punts/kicks.
Some thoughts.....
1) no-one else has stepped up.
2) how about that speed ?
3) he's got the "hands" to receive kicks, obviously, since he's a receiver (nevermind yesterday's non-call TD)
4) he did it somewhat in college, and the coach wanted to use him more there, but the only reason he didn't do it more, was because he was a starting receiver....which brings me to #5.......
5) he's not a starting receiver here, so we don't have to worry about risking injury to a key player.
I'm sure there's more reasons, but that's plenty. But I can't think of any reason not to.
So, why havn't I heard his name mentioned ?
Shanahan instead puts in Morgan to return kicks, because he's got a "big body".
Big Body ? What's the logic there ? Are we trying to do the complete opposite of Brandon Banks miniature frame, since the midget Banks was a dismal failure ? Come on, "being big" does not qualify you for being a returner. I don't support Banks' diminutive size, but the opposite - being big can actually work against you, as a returner.
Being "big" also makes you a bigger target to grab a hold of and tackle. Straight-ahead speed is more important. And agility. And Morgan certainly doesn't have those as his strengths. Aldrick does. So why isn't he being considered ? Is he in the dog-house ?
Last edited:
