I understand what both of you guys are saying, but my favorite Skins have always been the "grab your hardhat and go to work," kinda guys.
Was Monte Coleman a dominant player? Not really. He had a big play knack, but for the most part, he was just a solid guy who led by example. He's also my all-time favorite Redskin.
I'm not real happy about Reed at FS. He almost seems too hesitant to take a risk sometimes. There was a play in the Bills game where he could've jumped the route and maybe had a pick, but he was content to make the tackle after a 15-yard gain or so.
I think the knock on his speed is pretty ridiculous though. (Not that it's been made in this thread. He regularly runs step-for-step with the fastest guys on the field, but he gets beat by a fingertip. Which, yes, is still getting beat.) His 40 isn't great, but he does have football speed.
Still, as one of the most sure tacklers on the team, I'd rather seem him at strong, almost acting like a fifth LB of sorts. I think Landry, for all of HIS flaws, is better suited to play out of position than is Reed.