Message boards are an interesting social phenomenon. People who choose to spend a significant amount of time on a message board tend to do so on subjects that they are passionate about. So the discussion by definition tends to become emotional. Likewise the message board friendships that are created can be as real as those in “real life.”
Having come from CPND like CounterTrey, I know exactly what he is talking about. During last season the board became overwhelmed with “Campbell Sucks”, “Zorn Sucks,” and “Danny-boy” threads. Likewise the pendulum can swing in the other direction, where posters who previously viewed Mike Shanahan as the devil’s seed, were suddenly lauding his every move once he became the Redskin coach. In both cases, the emotions involved can end up being directed toward other posters, who do not share the board’s current overwhelming tone.
So threads like this are going to happen and the emotions expressed by CounterTrey and Sarge are going to be expressed. I believe that will only become a problem when these types of emotions overwhelm the overall tenor of the board. (The occasional rant is, I believe good for the soul.)
One of the things that attracted me to this board was that even during the lowest parts of last season, this board maintained a less emotional (and dare I say a more cerebral
) overall style. The challenge going forward will be to manage the emotion and to assimilate new members into the BGO culture, as those new members also contribute to and energize the environment. If not done properly, they board can change so much that old timers can find themselves as unwanted strangers in boards that they have posted on for years. On the other hand, the lack of new members can cause a board to slowly die.
Having known CounterTrey for many years (through the internet) and having observed Sarge for the last few months, I can say one thing with certainty; they are more likely to find common ground discussing politics than they are discussing Dan Snyder.
But what underlies their disagreement with regards to Dan Snyder and season tickets is the underlying passion we feel toward the Redskins that we all feel (otherwise we wouldn’t spend so much time on them.)
I do disagree with CounterTrey on the point that the play on the field doesn’t matter. I have seen the Redskins win and the Redskins lose. Winning is better.