Half of my family are Giants fans, When Eli was benched, they unanimously proclaimed HALL OF FAME! I never saw him as elite, even in his prime. Then I came across this article that sums it up pretty accurately for anyone who think he deserves to be in the HOF. To me, he is a perfect example of why Super Bowl wins should not be a measure for enshrinement.
https://weei.radio.com/articles/column/eli-manning-not-hall-fame-quarterback
https://weei.radio.com/articles/column/eli-manning-not-hall-fame-quarterback